All posts
Year in review12 min read

Supreme Court decisions of 2025: the year in review

The 100 Supreme Court rulings of 2025 that changed or clarified the law, by Bar subject, and every doctrine the Court abandoned during the year.

The Supreme Court decided 461 cases in 2025 that are now posted to its e-Library, and every one has a plain-language and lawyer-mode summary in our reader. By Bar subject: Criminal Law 117, Legal Ethics 70, Political Law 69, Civil Law 66, Remedial Law 61, Labor Law 31, Commercial Law 24 and Taxation 23.

About a fifth of them changed, clarified or newly applied a doctrine, or decided a question of wide public interest. This review covers those 100. The rest apply settled rules, and you can browse them by month in the 2025 decision summaries.

The ones to know

The impeachment of the Vice President was void. In Duterte v. House of Representatives (G.R. No. 278353, July 25, 2025), the Court held that impeachment is subject to judicial review and to the Bill of Rights. The fourth complaint against Vice President Duterte was barred by the one-year rule, and was also void because she was denied the opportunity to be heard. (The Court denied reconsideration with finality in January 2026.)

The PhilHealth fund transfer was unconstitutional. In Pimentel III v. House of Representatives (G.R. Nos. 274778, 275405, and 276233, December 3, 2025), the budget-law provision and the DOF circular that moved PhilHealth's reserve funds to the Treasury were struck down. The Court found an inappropriate rider in the budget law, a violation of the rule on special funds, and a breach of the right to health. The PHP 60 billion must be returned.

R.A. 7610 is narrowed. Gramatica v. People (G.R. Nos. 260233 and 266039, August 12, 2025) confines Section 5(b) of R.A. 7610 to children who take part in a sexual act because of money, coercion or influence. Where force, intimidation or an unconscious victim is involved, the Revised Penal Code applies. We trace what followed in a separate post.

Photocopies count as duplicates. In People v. Lastimosa (G.R. No. 265758, February 3, 2025), under the 2019 Rules on Evidence, a photocopy is a duplicate, admissible like the original unless its authenticity is genuinely questioned or admitting it would be unfair. This abandons the distinction drawn in MCC Industrial.

The second-placer rule is gone. In Mangudadatu v. COMELEC (G.R. Nos. 260219 and 260231, April 22, 2025), decided en banc by votes of 7–6 and 8–5, a sitting mayor's claimed new domicile in another province was a material misrepresentation. When a winning candidate's certificate is cancelled, the second placer no longer takes the seat; the vice-governor succeeds under the Local Government Code.

Infidelity is psychological violence, and intent is presumed. Denying reconsideration in XXX v. People (G.R. No. 252739, August 19, 2025), the en banc Court held that marital infidelity is psychological violence under Section 5(i) of the Anti-VAWC law, and that the intent to cause anguish is presumed from it. Four Justices dissented. Earlier in the year, in XXX v. People (G.R. No. 264870, April 21, 2025), a division had acquitted a husband because intent to cause anguish was not proven. The en banc ruling now controls.

Doctrines abandoned or reversed in 2025

Besides MCC Industrial and the second-placer rule, the Court let go of several precedents in 2025:

  • People v. Balunsat. When the accused appeals, the whole case is opened, so the appellate court may convict of the graver offense charged without double jeopardy. See People v. XXX (G.R. No. 262846, February 18, 2025) (attempted rape, not unjust vexation) and People v. XXX (G.R. No. 260860, November 11, 2025) (two counts of statutory rape).
  • People v. Agito. Ordinary mitigating circumstances such as voluntary surrender now apply to reckless imprudence resulting in homicide. Failure to help the victim must be alleged in the Information before it can raise the penalty (Ilon v. People (G.R. No. 260538, November 11, 2025)).
  • Crediting a nuisance candidate's votes. Under automated elections, votes cast for a nuisance candidate are stray and no longer go to a candidate with a similar name (Amutan v. COMELEC (G.R. No. 266331, December 3, 2025)).
  • Republic v. Desierto and Corpus, Jr. v. People, prospectively. A complaint filed with the prosecutor now tolls prescription, and prescription runs from discovery only for violations that were truly unknown (People v. Consebido (G.R. No. 258563, April 2, 2025), a tax-crime case).
  • Misconduct without a link to official duties. Misconduct must relate directly to official duties; other acts are prejudicial conduct instead (Medel v. Guillen (A.M. Nos. P-25-225, August 5, 2025)).

Three rulings were reversed on reconsideration: the SEC may accredit external auditors after all (SEC v. 1Accountants Party-List (G.R. No. 246027, January 28, 2025)); the stock and transfer book, not the GIS, decides who is a stockholder (Lopez v. Lopez (G.R. Nos. 254957-58, April 21, 2025)); and interest fixed by the bank alone means the borrower is not in default, so the foreclosure fails (UCPB v. Ang (G.R. No. 222448, March 3, 2025)). On reconsideration in Hacienda San Isidro v. Villaruel (G.R. No. 220087, August 11, 2025), the Court also held that an employment relationship must be proven through the control test, and that Article 295 cannot establish it.

Two further rulings revised the Court's own figures. The guidelines on naming rape offenses and their minimum damages were amended in People v. ABC260708 (G.R. No. 260708, April 22, 2025) (PHP 150,000, PHP 100,000 or PHP 75,000 for each award, depending on the offense). And interest on delayed just compensation follows the BSP rate in force in each period; the Court called a flat 6% an aberration (City of Pasay v. Arellano University (G.R. No. 260038, May 7, 2025)).

Political Law

Elections

Macalintal v. Senate (G.R. Nos. E-02002, E-02010, E-02142, and E-02276, November 11, 2025) upholds R.A. No. 12232, which gives barangay and SK officials four-year terms and moves their elections to November 2026. The Court treated it as a law setting terms, not one postponing elections. Ali v. Bangsamoro Transition Authority Parliament (G.R. No. E-02219, September 30, 2025) struck down the BARMM redistricting law passed during the election period, and reset the first parliamentary elections to no later than March 31, 2026. Alminaza v. COMELEC (G.R. No. 277969, October 28, 2025) holds that the automated election law does not require a manual count at the precinct.

On candidates: COMELEC may disqualify only on grounds the law provides, and spreading false election information is an election offense that needs a conviction first (Erice v. COMELEC (G.R. No. 277608, July 8, 2025)). COMELEC must prove a nuisance candidacy by substantial evidence; unpopularity or lack of funds is not a ground (Mustapha v. COMELEC (G.R. No. 277177, July 8, 2025)), and neither are pending criminal charges or detention (Matula v. COMELEC (G.R. No. 277784, August 5, 2025), the Quiboloy candidacy). Carrying a knife during the election period is not an election offense, because COMELEC had no power to add bladed weapons to the ban (Macabuhay v. People (G.R. No. 270337, August 13, 2025)). COMELEC's recognition of the Cusi-led officers of PDP Laban was upheld (Pimentel v. COMELEC (G.R. No. 265395, July 8, 2025)). And when a House seat falls vacant, COMELEC must call the special election on its own (Hagedorn v. House of Representatives (G.R. No. 275800, April 22, 2025)).

Congressional inquiries

The year produced a body of law on legislative inquiries. A resource person cannot refuse to testify altogether; the right against self-incrimination is invoked question by question, and there is no custodial right to counsel (Ong v. Senate Tricomm (G.R. No. 275469, May 6, 2025)). A House committee may detain someone who ignores its summons without a court warrant, even during adjournment (In re Habeas Corpus of Dolor (G.R. No. 279692, June 11, 2025)). Questions need only be pertinent to the subject of the inquiry, not to a specific bill (Guo v. Senate (G.R. No. 274351, August 12, 2025)). An invitation to testify about fake news is not prior restraint, and privilege speeches are beyond judicial review (Abines v. House of Representatives (G.R. No. 278101, July 8, 2025)).

Local governments

A province cannot impose a blanket ban on large-scale mining, though it may withhold approval of specific projects (Province of Occidental Mindoro v. Agusan Petroleum and Mineral Corp. (G.R. No. 248932, January 14, 2025)). Repealing an ordinance that abolished a barangay recreates the barangay, so a plebiscite and the population minimum are required (Sinag v. Sangguniang Panlalawigan ng Batangas (G.R. No. 234228, February 25, 2025)). Barangays may hold bingo to raise funds without a PAGCOR permit (Republic v. Association of Barangay Councils (G.R. No. 207118, April 22, 2025)).

The executive, public officers and public funds

R.A. No. 10531, which gives the NEA power to supervise and take over electric cooperatives, is a valid exercise of police power (PHILFECO v. Ochoa (G.R. Nos. 207894 and 209380, November 11, 2025)). The 2024 DOJ rules on preliminary investigation do not encroach on the Court's rule-making power (Meking v. Remulla (G.R. No. 280455, November 11, 2025)). PNP penalties short of demotion or dismissal cannot be appealed to the Civil Service Commission (Arturo v. Albayalde (G.R. No. 250804, February 25, 2025)). A government employee who tests positive for drugs is dismissed only if they refuse or fail treatment (Salomon v. City Government of Muntinlupa (G.R. No. 260742, May 20, 2025)).

The SEC's exemption from the compensation laws does not free it from presidential control over salary increases, though the recipients were excused from refunding (SEC v. COA (G.R. Nos. 263919 and 264033, January 28, 2025)). Property out of proportion to a public officer's lawful income is presumed ill-gotten even when held by relatives (Heirs of Ligot v. Republic (G.R. No. 257827, March 5, 2025)). The HLURB's jurisdiction over unsound real estate practices covers only complaints by buyers (Miracle Heights Development v. Court of Appeals (G.R. No. 270086, September 30, 2025)).

Labor Law

An accepted job offer is already a binding contract, so withdrawing it without proven cause is illegal dismissal (Aragones v. Alltech Biotechnology Corp. (G.R. No. 251736, April 2, 2025)). Companies may contract out even their core work, but whether a contractor is legitimate is judged worker by worker (Sanyo Seiki Stainless Steel Corp. v. Amago (G.R. Nos. 275229 and 275678, August 11, 2025)).

Bacani v. Fiber Textile Manufacturing Corp. (G.R. No. 271518, September 30, 2025) sets four requisites for flexible work arrangements that reduce pay: majority consent, temporariness, notice to DOLE and real economic difficulty. Missing only the DOLE notice costs PHP 100,000 per worker; missing the others is constructive dismissal. Where salaries are paid by bank credit, the employer must at least prove the bank received the payroll (PAL v. Ahmee (G.R. No. 221065, April 7, 2025)).

In Suazo v. Tri Megaforce Security Services (G.R. No. 276106, August 20, 2025), the Court on its own referred a lawyer to the IBP for citing Supreme Court decisions that do not exist or say something else. That is a warning for anyone drafting with AI tools.

Civil Law

Family

A child legitimated by the parents' later marriage stays legitimate even after the marriage is declared void for psychological incapacity (Republic v. Tangarorang (G.R. No. 272006, February 5, 2025)). "Grossly abusive conduct", a ground for legal separation, is now defined: acts that create a hostile and intimidating environment, physical violence not required (Go v. Chan-Go (G.R. No. 243647, November 18, 2025)). Philippine courts can nullify a bigamous marriage celebrated abroad, and a foreign spouse may file (De Munari v. Asprec (G.R. No. 262831, April 7, 2025)).

Torts and damages

Civil indemnity for death caused by negligence rises from PHP 50,000 to PHP 300,000, to be recomputed every five years. A school was held solidarily liable for a student's death at a campus event (University of Southeastern Philippines v. Sarate (G.R. No. 247617, November 25, 2025)). Between rival networks, good-faith reporting and fair comment are privileged, and truth is a defense against a public figure (GMA Network v. ABS-CBN (G.R. Nos. 263599 and 263643, November 3, 2025)).

Property

Accion publiciana does not have to wait until a year of dispossession has passed (Spouses Agullo v. Victa-Espinosa (G.R. No. 269921, April 22, 2025)). Written notice is still required to start the period for legal redemption, but knowledge of the sale plus laches can excuse it (Azurin v. Chua (G.R. No. 259662, April 23, 2025)).

Taxation

The BIR cannot use distraint or garnishment without a valid assessment when the return shows no tax due (CIR v. Stradcom Corp. (G.R. No. 255520, April 21, 2025)). The CREATE Act regulations that limited VAT zero-rating to export enterprises are void (Subic Bay Freeport Chamber of Commerce v. Department of Finance (G.R. No. 266016, February 4, 2025)). A tax-assumption clause is not a tax exemption, so COA's charge against the Malampaya contractors was lifted (Shell Philippines Exploration B.V. v. COA (G.R. No. 238846, February 25, 2025)).

A PEZA enterprise pays 12% VAT on goods and services it uses outside the ecozone, and that input VAT is refundable (Coral Bay Nickel Corp. v. CIR (G.R. Nos. 251333-34, March 5, 2025)). The CIR, not Customs, decides refunds of excise tax on imports (Commissioner of Customs v. Air Philippines (G.R. No. 249407, April 23, 2025)). The CTA en banc has no certiorari jurisdiction over a division's interlocutory orders (CIR v. Nippon Express Philippines (G.R. No. 271701, May 6, 2025)).

Commercial Law

An opposer must prove likelihood of confusion with evidence; similarity of marks alone is not enough (Innolab Industries v. United Laboratories (G.R. No. 257075, August 5, 2025), en banc). A 20-second ringtone preview is communication to the public, but it was fair use (FILSCAP v. Wolfpac Communications (G.R. No. 184661, February 25, 2025)). A club that issues shares but cannot pay dividends is a non-stock corporation (Forest Hills Golf and Country Club v. SEC (G.R. No. 256634, July 25, 2025)).

On banking and money laundering: a cybercrime warrant can compel a bank to identify an account holder, because bank secrecy protects deposits, not identities (EastWest Rural Bank v. PNP Anti-Cybercrime Group (G.R. No. 273720, July 29, 2025)). AMLA freeze orders may reach related accounts (Manganip v. Republic (G.R. No. 222312, May 20, 2025)).

Criminal Law

Graft and public funds

Breaking procurement rules is not graft by itself (People v. Estregan (G.R. No. 248699, February 5, 2025)). Plunder absorbs graft by receiving kickbacks, but not graft by giving unwarranted benefits to private parties (Estrada v. Sandiganbayan (G.R. Nos. 228374-84, 236268, 249296, 249919, 254892, and 254906-15, October 28, 2025)). FAPE's funds are public funds (Arcelo v. People (G.R. No. 235870, February 5, 2025)). In B.P. 22 cases, the corporate officer liable on a company check is whoever signed it (Rebujio v. Dio Implant Philippines (G.R. No. 269745, January 14, 2025)).

Crimes against persons

Fulfillment of duty did not excuse police officers who shot a restrained minor; the murder convictions stood (People v. Pereda (G.R. Nos. 268510 and 274142, August 11, 2025)). Being present at the planning or approving a plot is not an overt act of conspiracy, and an acquittal stood (People v. Ampatuan, Sr. (G.R. No. 258710, January 27, 2025)). Intoxication mitigates only when acts such as slurred speech show it (Ilayat v. People (G.R. No. 259916, July 25, 2025)). Gestures alone can be grave threats, but not a flash of anger (Israel v. People (G.R. No. 265736, November 19, 2025)).

Drugs

Life imprisonment as the maximum for possessing 5 to under 10 grams of shabu applies only in the circumstances listed in Section 13 (People v. Paterno (G.R. No. 256964, August 13, 2025)). Skipping an evidence bag is not automatically fatal to the chain of custody (People v. Soriano (G.R. No. 257747, February 5, 2025)). See also People v. Ildefonso (G.R. No. 249858, February 19, 2025), which also held that bladed weapons are not "deadly weapons" under the COMELEC ban.

VAWC

Besides the infidelity rulings above: who owns a social media account, and who wrote a post, can be proven by circumstantial evidence, under new guideposts (XXX v. People (G.R. No. 274842, October 22, 2025)). Harassment under Section 5(h) requires proof of real distress and a culpable mental state (XXX v. People (G.R. No. 263779, December 3, 2025)).

Remedial Law

Criminal procedure

An acquittal can be reviewed only after a sham trial or a similar denial of due process (People v. Canoy (G.R. No. 271427, May 19, 2025)). An accused who flees loses standing to ask the courts for relief until he surrenders (Vallacar Transit v. Yanson (G.R. No. 259337, November 25, 2025), adopting the fugitive disentitlement doctrine). Courts may approve drug plea bargains over a prosecution objection based only on DOJ guidelines (Aquino v. People (G.R. No. 259094, January 28, 2025)). Prisoners serving three years or less may be moved to less crowded jails only with the court's prior approval (Re: Jail Transfer of PDLs Sentenced to Three Years and Below (A.M. No. 25-01-25-SC, November 11, 2025)).

Special writs and ADR

Amparo and habeas data writs issue on a prima facie showing, and an amparo grant carries an implied no-approach restriction (Castro v. Dela Cruz (G.R. No. 269249, May 6, 2025)). An arbitration is international when the parties do business in different states (GS Yuasa Corp. v. Ramcar, Inc. (G.R. No. 252787, May 7, 2025)). Where the arbitration clause adopts R.A. 876, the RTC appoints the arbitrator (Ionics EMS v. Noblejas (G.R. No. 259885, August 27, 2025)).

Civil procedure

E-mail service of a final order does not start the period to appeal (So v. Food Fest Land, Inc. (G.R. No. 261784, April 2, 2025)). Public officials' salaries may be garnished (Bagbagen v. Perez (G.R. No. 274980, February 17, 2025)). Land Bank is a public corporation for service of summons (Beltran v. Land Bank of the Philippines (G.R. No. 243507, September 29, 2025)). Dismissal for failure to state a cause of action looks only at the complaint and its annexes (Taganile v. Dolar (G.R. No. 262480, October 29, 2025)). Automatic referral to the DAR requires that the pleadings allege an agrarian dispute (Domingo v. Ordonio (G.R. No. 272134, September 29, 2025)). When spouses file legal separation cases against each other, the later case now waits for the first to be resolved (Santos v. Santos (G.R. No. 267675, May 20, 2025)).

The Judicial Integrity Board became the Judicial Integrity Office (Re: Reorganizing the Judicial Integrity Board as the Judicial Integrity Office (A.M. No. 23-12-05-SC, March 4, 2025)). An applicant for a judgeship must keep the JBC informed of every complaint until appointment (Judicial Integrity Office v. Judge Cinco IV (A.M. Nos. RTJ-25-114, December 3, 2025)). A judge found to have induced a fellow judge's murder was dismissed and disbarred while his conviction was still on appeal (JIB v. Judge Tomarong (A.M. Nos. RTJ-25-085, July 29, 2025)). A pending criminal case no longer by itself stops a Bar passer from taking the oath (In re: Taloma (B.M. No. 4530, December 3, 2025)). Habitual tardiness that does not disrupt work is now a light charge (Employees' Leave Division, OCA v. Mataro (A.M. Nos. P-24-192, May 20, 2025)).

Lawyers were disbarred for misconduct in their private lives: attempted bribery and abuse of family members (Romero v. Romero (A.C. No. 9272, July 29, 2025)) and deceiving a friend in an investment scheme (Dator-Miles v. Monge (A.C. No. 14378, April 2, 2025)). A profane post on social media drew a one-year suspension (Baltao v. Atty. Falcis (A.C. No. 14443, November 18, 2025)). Complaints against notaries now follow Canon VI of the CPRA (Guerrero v. Gonzaga (A.C. No. 10317, July 29, 2025)).

Pangkalahatang impormasyon lamang ito para sa edukasyon — hindi ito legal advice, at hindi ito sinuri ng abogado. Sinikap naming tama ito ayon sa batas na binanggit, pero para sa sarili mong kaso, kumonsulta sa abogado o sa Public Attorney's Office (PAO). Each summary here is drawn from the decision’s full text, which is linked from every case name; read the decision itself before relying on it.