HomeJurisprudence2021Aug

Decisions in Aug 2021

26

Decisions

01

G.R. No. 204567 EMILIANO D. JOVEN, AND CICERO V. GARCIA PETITIONERS, VS. SPOUSES RAUL L. TULIO AND CRISTINA PANGANIBAN TULIO, RESPONDENTS. August 04, 2021

02

G.R. No. 233118 SEBASTIAN TAMARES, SUBSTITUTED BY OFELIA TAMARES PANELO, PETITIONER, VS. HEIRS OF NATIVIDAD AND RAFAEL DE GUIA, SR., REPRESENTED BY ROMEO DE GUIA, CARIDAD DE GUIA, RAFAEL DE GUIA, AND SUSAN DE GUIA, RESPONDENTS. August 04, 2021

03

G.R. No. 203946 ARTURO A. DACQUEL, PETITIONER, VS. SPOUSES ERNESTO SOTELO AND FLORA DACQUEL­SOTELO, REPRESENTED BY THEIR ATTORNEY-IN-FACT, IMELDA SOTELO, RESPONDENTS. August 04, 2021

04

G.R. No. 213001 LAURO CARDINEZ, ISIDRO CARDINEZ, JESUS CARDINEZ, VIRGIE CARDINEZ, FLORA LACONSAY AND AIDA DELA CRUZ, PETITIONERS, VS. SPOUSES PRUDENCIO AND CRESENCIA CARDINEZ, RESPONDENTS. August 04, 2021

05

G.R. No. 213400 ELIDAD KHO AND VIOLETA KHO, PETITIONERS, VS. SUMMERVILLE GENERAL MERCHANDISING & CO., INC., RESPONDENT. August 04, 2021

06

G.R. No. 201380 ARTURO O. RADAZA, PETITIONER, VS. HON. SANDIGANBAYAN AND PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, RESPONDENTS. August 04, 2021

07

G.R. No. 204405 COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE, PETITIONER, VS. UNIOIL CORPORATION, RESPONDENT. August 04, 2021

08

G.R. No. 204997 EDILBERTO "EDDIE" PINEDA, MARIA FRANCISCO, FLORENCIO M. MANARANG, ROLANDO "ROLAN" AQUINO, ERNESTO P. VILLANUEVA, MERCEDES P. LACSINA, ANDRES A. FRANCISCO, BERNARDO V. GASTON, BASILIO A. ILANO, ADELAIDA VILLANUEVA, EULOGIO FRANCISCO, CRISANTO Q. AQUINO, EDUARDO P. NAVARRO, WILFREDO "JUNIOR" C. CAPULOY, JR., CHOLITA P. SANTOS, ALVIN LUGTU, JOSE BALBOA, REYNALDO "REY" LUGTU, ESTRELITA "ESTER" C. LUGTU, MELQUIADES MANARANG, OFRECINA PINEDA, RICARDO L. BALBOA, FILEMON F. FRANCISCO, PEDRO F. FRANCISCO, CASTOR I. YUNUN, PEDRO P. UNGOS, LUDOVICO "RUDY" P. UNGOS, WILFREDO "WILLY" BANDOLA, NOEL "NONONG" PALO, JESUS M. FRANCISCO, EDUARDO "EDDIE" COLLADO, SONNY LACSINA, FERNANDO "NANDY" COLLADO, BENJAMIN "AMIN" DELA CRUZ, RIZALINO "RIZAL" MATIC, CEZAR RAMIREZ, GERRY GASTON, EDUARDO FRANCISCO, ERNESTO TAYAG, NESTOR AQUINO, BERT AQUINO, AVELINO MANUCDUC, ARNEL NAVARRO, GREGORIO EMATA, ARTURO ZURBITO, LILIA DAVID, DOMINGO "BOND" CADIANG, JR., EDUARDO BALTAZAR, AMMONIO "AMON" DUMLAO, PEPITO Q. LUGTU, EDUARDO "EDDIE" PALO, DOMINGA PUNO, JOSEPH "JOSE" CORTEZ, BIENVENIDO BALBOA, ROSE MANQUIL, ROMEL BALBOA, ARSENIA PALO, WILFREDO "WILLY" FRANCISCO, CELADONIA VILLANUEVA, EMILIO GARCIA, ROLANDO "RODON" MARCOS, JIMMY NAVARRO, JUANITO FRANCISCO, ERNESTO NAVARRO, MARINA JACINTO, ROLANDO LUGTU, JESUS JACINTO, CORNELIO GAMPOY, DAVID DANDAN, ORLANDO TABLANTE, NIDA SOLAMO, ABELARDO YUMUL, LAURO MALIG, ORLANDO DELA CRUZ, EFIFANIO* MAGAT JR., CONRADO CASTRO, RODEL PALO, RODRIGO DELA CRUZ, EFREN DELA CRUZ, EVA CHAVEZ, ILDEFONSO "BOY" RAMOS, JR., MARIO DEQUINON, NOLITO CARBUNGCO CRISANTO** LAURONILLA, HENRY SANTOS, RODERICK UNGOS, LEANDO PENAREDONDO, BONIFACIO OJANO, SEVERO JAVIER, ROGER FAJARDO, SIANO COLLADO, ERLINDA TIMPUG, AND ROYNALDO "ROY" DELA CRUZ, PETITIONERS, VS. ABELARDO C. MIRANDA, ELIAS C. MIRANDA AND CARMENCITA D. MIRANDA, RESPONDENTS. August 04, 2021

09

G.R. No. 212126 HEIRS OF ELISEO BAGAYGAY, NAMELY: ANECITA P. BAGAYGAY, ELADIO BAGAYGAY, INOCENCIO BAGAYGAY, AND MARY MAE BAGAYGAY, PETITIONERS, VS. HEIRS OF ANASTACIO PACIENTE, NAMELY: MEREGILDO PACIENTE, ADELAIDA P. TUAZON, CECILIA P. KWAN, FRANCIS ROY PACIENTE, FERNANDO PACIENTE, ARTURO PACIENTE, ANASTACIO PACIENTE, JR., MELAGROSA P. MONTEJO, MAGDALENA P. ORLIDO, RESPONDENTS. August 04, 2021

10

G.R. No. 216587 SPOUSES EUGENIO PONCE AND EMILIANA NEROSA, PETITIONERS, VS. JESUS ALDANESE, RESPONDENT. August 04, 2021

11

G.R. No. 217583 IGNACIO S. DUMARAN, PETITIONER, VS. TERESA LLAMEDO, SHARON MAGALLANES AND GINALYN CUBETA, RESPONDENTS. August 04, 2021

12

G.R. No. 234999 HEIRS OF BARTOLOME J. SANCHEZ, REPRESENTED BY EDNA N. VDA. DE SANCHEZ, PETITIONERS, VS. HELDELITA, ALLEN, ALBERTO, ARTHUR, MARIA ANITA, ALL SURNAMED ABRANTES, RESPONDENTS. August 04, 2021

13

G.R. No. 241699 DENNIS T. UY TUAZON, WORLD WISER INTERNATIONAL, INC., AND JERZON MANPOWER AND TRADING, INC., PETITIONERS, VS. MYRA V. FUENTES, RESPONDENTS. August 04, 2021

14

G.R. No. 252865 PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, VS. YYY,* ACCUSED-APPELLANT. August 04, 2021

15

G.R. No. 249002 PSI DINO WALLY COGASI, SPO2 JERRY SILAWON, SPO1 REYNALDO BADUA, AND PO2 GEOFFREY BANTULE, PETITIONERS, VS. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, SONNY RUFINO, JULIET ARCITA, JAY ARCITA, AND CARLOS TICAWA, RESPONDENTS. August 04, 2021

16

G.R. No. 255602 JOY M. VILLARICO, PETITIONER, VS. D.M. CONSUNJI, INC., AND MADELINE B. GACUTAN, RESPONDENTS. August 04, 2021

17

G.R. No. 235358 DOMINGO A. PADSING, MARCIAL A. BACASEN, WENDELL D. NARCISO, AND RUNDELL JAY M. SIDO, PETITIONERS, VS. LEPANTO CONSOLIDATED MINING COMPANY AND BRYAN U. YAP, RESPONDENTS. August 04, 2021

18

G.R. No. 210072 CF SHARP CREW MANAGEMENT INC., NORWEGIAN CRUISE LINES INC., AND JICKIE ILAGAN, PETITIONERS, VS. MANUEL M. CUNANAN, RESPONDENT. August 04, 2021

19

G.R. No. 203942 RHODORA R. MORENO, PETITIONER, VS. CHATEAU ROYALE SPORTS AND COUNTRY CLUB, INC., JOEL GO, ROWELL DAVID, ROLANDO BASILIO AND JAN MICHEL GAUTIER,* RESPONDENTS. August 04, 2021

20

A.C. No. 6766 MOISES ANACAY, COMPLAINANT, VS. ATTY. GERARDO WILFREDO L. ALBERTO, RESPONDENT. August 04, 2021

21

G.R. No. 207958 MIGUELA QUITALIG, PETITIONER, VS. ELADIO QUITALIG, RESPONDENT. August 04, 2021

22

A.M. No. CA-20-36-P DR. VIRGILIO S. RODIL, COMPLAINANT, VS. IMELDA V. POSADAS, RECORDS OFFICER II, REPORTERS DIVISION, COURT OF APPEALS, RESPONDENT. August 03, 2021

23

G.R. No. 256285 MIGUEL RENE A. DOMINGUEZ, PETITIONER, VS. COMMISSION ON AUDIT, MICHAEL G. AGUINALDO IN HIS CAPACITY AS CHAIRPERSON, RESPONDENT. August 03, 2021

24

A.C. No. 11599 FLORESWINDA V. JUNI, COMPLAINANT, VS. ATTY. MARIO T. JUNI, RESPONDENT. August 03, 2021

25

G.R. No. 227467 ATTY. JOAQUIN DELOS SANTOS, ENGR. EVELYN M. HATULAN AND CORNELIO V. TAMAYO, PETITIONERS, VS. COMMISSION ON AUDIT, RESPONDENT. August 03, 2021

26

G.R. No. 210245 BAYAN MUNA REPRESENTATIVES NERI JAVIER COLMENARES AND CARLOS ISAGANI ZARATE, GABRIELA WOMEN'S PARTY REPRESENTATIVES LUZ ILAGAN AND EMMI DE JESUS, ACT TEACHERS PARTY-LIST REPRESENTATIVE ANTONIO TINIO, AND KABATAAN PARTY­LIST REPRESENTATIVE TERRY RIDON, PETITIONERS, VS. ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION (ERC) AND MANILA ELECTRIC COMPANY (MERALCO), RESPONDENTS. [G.R. No. 210255] NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF ELECTRICITY CONSUMERS FOR REFORMS (NASECORE), REPRESENTED BY PETRONILO L. ILAGAN, FEDERATION OF VILLAGE ASSOCIATIONS (FOYA), REPRESENTED BY SIEGFRIEDO A. VELOSO, FEDERATION OF LAS PIÑAS HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION (FOLPHA), REPRESENTED BY BONIFACIO DAZO AND RODRIGO C. DOMINGO, JR., PETITIONERS, VS. MANILA ELECTRIC COMPANY (MERALCO), ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION (ERC) AND DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY (DOE), ET AL. RESPONDENTS. [G.R. No. 210502] MANILA ELECTRIC COMPANY (MERALCO), PETITIONER, VS. PHILIPPINE ELECTRICITY MARKET CORPORATION, FIRST GAS POWER CORPORATION, SOUTH PREMIERE POWER CORPORATION, SAN MIGUEL ENERGY CORPORATION, MASINLOC POWER PARTNERS, CO., LTD., QUEZON POWER (PHILS.) LTD. CO., THERMA LUZON, INC., SEM-CALACA POWER CORPORATION, FGP CORPORATION AND NATIONAL GRID CORPORATION OF THE PHILIPPINES, AND THE FOLLOWING GENERATION COMPANIES THAT TRADE IN THE WESM NAMELY: 1590 ENERGY CORPORATION, AP RENEWABLES, INC., BAC-MAN ENERGY DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION/BAC-MAN GEOTHERMAL, INC., FIRST GEN HYDRO POWER CORPORATION, GNPOWER MARIVELES COAL PLANT LTD. CO., PANASIA ENERGY HOLDINGS, INC., POWER SECTOR ASSETS AND LIABILITIES MANAGEMENT CORPORATION, SN ABOITIZ POWER, STRATEGIC POWER DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION, BULACAN POWER GENERATION CORPORATION AND VIVANT STA. CLARA NORTHERN RENEWABLES GENERATION CORPORATION, RESPONDENTS. August 03, 2021