June 2006

179decisions
  1. 01G.r. No. 125041 Ma. Belen B. Mangonon, for and in Behalf of Her Minor Children Rebecca Angela Delgado and Regina Isabel Delgado. Petitioner, Vs.hon. Court of Appeals, Hon. Judge Josefina Guevara-Salonga, Presiding Judge, RTC-Makati, Branch 149, Federico C. Delgado and Francisco C. Delgado, Respondents.
  2. 02G.r. No. 138703 Development Bank of the Philippines[1] and Privatization and Management Office (Formerly Asset Privatization Trust), Petitioners, Vs. Hon. Court of Appeals, Philippine United Foundry and Machinery Corp. and Philippine Iron Manufacturing Co., Inc., Respondents.
  3. 03G.r. No. 138965 Public Interest Center Inc., Laureano T. Angeles, and Jocelyn P. Celestino, Petitioners, Vs. Magdangal B. Elma, as Chief Presidential Legal Counsel and as Chairman of the Presidential Commission on Good Government, and Ronaldo Zamora, as Executive Secretary, Respondents.
  4. 04G.r. No. 140796 Purificacion Perez-Rosario, Federico Rosario, Ricardo Perez, Maria Paz Perez-Pasion, Gualberto Perez, Ladislao Perez, Marcelo Perez and Teodora Perez, Petitioners, Vs. Hon. Court of Appeals, Adjudication Board of the Department of Agrarian Reform, Mercedes Resultay, Basilio Cayabyab, Federico Baniqued, and Miguel Resultay (Deceased) Substituted by His Heir, Arturo Resultay, Respondents.
  5. 05G.r. No. 141964 Spouses Edesito and Consorcia Ragasa, Petitioners, Vs. Spouses Gerardo and Rodriga Roa and the Ex-Officio Sheriff of Quezon City, Respondents.
  6. 06G.r. No. 142848 Eugene C. Yu, Petitioner, Vs. the Honorable Presiding Judge, Regional Trial Court of Tagaytay City, Branch 18, the Honorable Secretary of the Department of Justice, Assistant Provincial Prosecutor Jose M. Velasco, Sec. Teofisto T. Guingona, Rodolfo Ochoa and Reynaldo de Los Santos a.k.a. "Engine," Respondents.
  7. 07G.r. No. 143664 Marison C. Basuel, Petitioner, Vs. Fact-Finding and Intelligence Bureau (Ffib) Represented by Director Agapito B. Rosales, Respondent.
  8. 08G.r. No. 144054 Nieves a. Saguiguit, Petitioner, Vs. People of the Philippines, Respondent.
  9. 09G.r. No. 148357 Aniano a. Albon, Petitioner,vs. Bayani F. Fernando, City Mayor of Marikina, Engr. Alfonso Espirito, City Engineer of Marikina, Engr. Anaki Maderal, Assistant City Engineer of Marikina, and Natividad Cabalquinto, City Treasurer of Marikina, Respondents.
  10. 10G.r. No. 149051 Biblia T. Banaga, Petitioner, Vs. Hon. Jose S. Majaducon, Presiding Judge Regional Trial Court, Court, Branch Xxiii, 11th Judicial Region, General Santos City and Candelario S. Damalerio, Respondents.
  11. 11G.r. No. 149489 Private Enterprise Corporation, Petitioner, Vs. Reynaldo Magada, Respondent.
  12. 12G.r. No. 150865 Art Fuentebella, Park-in-Charge, and Rolling Hills Memorial Park, Inc., Petitioners, Vs. Darlica Castro, Respondent.
  13. 13G.r. No. 158075 Philippine Diamond Hotel and Resort, Inc. (Manila Diamond Hotel), Petitioner, Vs. Manila Diamond Hotel Employees Union, Respondent.
  14. 14G.r. No. 159674 Samuel Estribillo, Calixto P. Abayato, Jr., Rongie D. Aguilar, Taciana D. Aguilar, Artemio G. de Juan, Estanislao dela Cruz, Sr., Edgar Duenas, Mario Eribal, Reynaldo C. Esencia, Emma Gonzaga, Ruben a. Ibojo, Samuel Jamandre, Hilarion v. Lantiza, Anselmo Lopez, Teresita Nacion, Charie E. Nastor, Nelson L. Nullas, Carlito S. Olia, Ana Patiño, Roberto T. Patiño, Antonio P. Rocha, Fernando C. Rufino,paterno P. Sain, Claudio S. Sayson, and Joemarie Vibo, Petitioners, Vs. Department of Agrarian Reform and Hacienda Maria, Inc., Respondents.
  15. 15G.r. No. 160514 General Milling Corporation, Petitioner, Vs. Tirso Uytengsu III, Kathleen Uytengsu-Tan and Barbara Uytengsu-Tan, Respondents.[***]
  16. 16G.r. No. 161970 Dundee a. Viernes, Petitioner, Vs. People of the Philippines, Respondent.
  17. 17G.r. No. 163511 Lee Hiong Wee, Petitioner, Vs. Dee Ping Wee and Marina U. Tan, Respondents.
  18. 18G.r. No. 163663 Greater Metropolitan Manila Solid Waste Management Committee and the Metropolitan Manila Development Authority, Petitioners, Vs. Jancom Environmental Corporation and Jancom International Development Projects Pty. Limited of Australia, Respondents.
  19. 19G.r. No. 165073 Heirs of Juan Griño, Sr. Represented by Remedios C. Griño, Petitioners, Vs. Department of Agrarian Reform, Respondent.
  20. 20G.r. No. 164801 Philippine National Bank, Petitioner, Vs. Heirs of Estanislao Militar and Deogracias Militar, Represented by Tranquilina Militar, Respondents. G.r. No. 165165 Spouses Johnny Lucero and Nona Ariete, Petitioners, Vs. Heirs of Estanislao Militar, Deogracias Militar, and Tranquilina Militar (Deceased), Now Represented by Azucena Militar, Freddie Militar, Eduardo Militar, Romeo L. Militar, Nelly Ly Bolanio, Leticia Ly and Delia Ly Si Asoyco, Respondents.
  21. 21G.r. No. 165711 Hermoso Arriola and Melchor Radan, Petitioners, Vs. Sandiganbayan, Respondent.
  22. 22G.r. No. 166279 Philippine Rabbit Bus Lines, Inc., Petitioner, Vs. Aladdin Transit Corp., Anacleto Villarico and Esteban Zipagan, Respondents.
  23. 23G.r. No. 167400 Priscilla T. Rigor, Enrico T. Rigor, Jesus Romeo T. Rigor and Nino Angelo T. Rigor, Petitioners, Vs. Tenth Division of the Court of Appeals and Milagros Rodriguez, Respondents.
  24. 24G.r. No. 167270 Philippine National Bank, Petitioner, Vs. Helen Joyce Campos, Respondent.
  25. 25G.r. No. 169177 Sps. Dan T. Paguirigan and Mary Jane Paguirigan, Petitioners, Vs. Pilhino Sales Corporation, Respondent.
  26. 26G.r. No. 170354 Edgardo Pinga, Petitioner, Vs. the Heirs of German Santiago Represented by Fernando Santiago, Respondents.
  27. 27G.r. No. 167813 Benjamin L. Sarocam, Petitioner, Vs. Interorient Maritime Ent., Inc., and Demaco United Ltd., Respondents.
  28. 28G.r. No. 150464 Security Bank and Trust Company, Petitioner, Vs. Eric Gan, Respondent.
  29. 29A.c. No. 6057 Peter T. Donton, Complainant, Vs. Atty. Emmanuel O. Tansingco, Respondent.
  30. 30A.m. No. P-06-2183 (Formerly a.m. No. 06-5-157-MTC) Absence Without Official Leave (Awol) of Alberto v. Monsanto, Metropolitan Trial Court, Catbalogan, Samar
  31. 31A.m. No. Mtj-05-1604 (Formerly Oca I.p.i. No. 04-1580-Mtj) Marites O. Tam, Complainant, Vs. Judge Jocelyn G. Regencia, Municipal Circuit Trial Court(Mctc), Asturias-Balamban,cebu, Respondent.
  32. 32A.m. No. P-06-2177 (Formerly a.m. No. 06-4-268-RTC) Re: Report on the Financial Audit Conducted on the Books of Accounts of Atty. Raquel G. Kho, Clerk of Court IV, Regional Trial Court, Oras, Eastern Samar.
  33. 33A.m. No. Rtj-05-1903 (Formerly Oca Ipi No. 04-2022-Rtj) Pc/insp. Marcelo B. Dayag, Complainant, Vs. Judge Teodora R. Gonzales, Judge Herminio Z. Canlas,[*] and Atty. Araceli S. Crisostomo, Respondents.
  34. 34A.m. No. Sb-04-12-P (Formerly a.m. No. 03-11-01-Sb) Alberto P. Abogado, Jr., Security Officer I, Complainant, Vs. Ferdinand L. Gurtiza, Security Guard III, and Elberto Q. Bautista, Security Guard II, Sandiganbayan, Quezon City, Respondents.
  35. 35G.r. No. 124512 Ma. Rosario Suarez, Petitioner, Vs. Judge Martin S. Villarama, Jr., RTC, Pasig City, Branch 156 and Sps. Escolastico & Cordelia Ballar, Respondents.
  36. 36G.r. No. 130584 Yazaki Torres Manufacturing, Inc., Petitioner, Vs. the Court of Appeals, the Home Development Mutual Fund, Through Its Board of Trustees, and Honorable Zorayda Amelia C. Alonzo, in Her Capacity as President of the Home Development Mutual Fund, Respondents.
  37. 37G.r. No. 142534 Donato Sumaway, Joseph Alvero, Asia Gold Coast Corporation, Akigonz Corporation, Raul F. Reyes, Ermelyn Reyes, Leome G. Gata, Antonio Hicap, Dolores Yanga, Imelda Magat, Honorio Guevarra, Edgewater Entertainment Corporation, Carolina Yutuc, Osiphil, Inc., Renato Lauchengco, Alexander Angulo and Joseph Jamboy, Petitioners, Vs. Urban Bank, Inc., Isabela Sugar Company, Inc., Magdaleno M. Peña and Ernesto Ochoa, Respondents.
  38. 38G.r. No. 143362 Cynthia v. Omadle and Angelito Alisen, Petitioners, Vs. Spouses Wilfredo and Rogelia B. Casuno, Respondents.
  39. 39G.r. No. 144215 the Manila Electric Company, Petitioner, Vs. South Pacific Plastic Manufacturing Corporation, Respondent. [g.r. No. 144300] South Pacific Plastic Manufacturing Corporation, Petitioner, Vs. the Manila Electric Company, Respondent.
  40. 40G.r. No. 145945 People of the Philippines, Petitioner, Vs. Victor Subida, Respondent.
  41. 41G.r. No. 146426 Cargolift Shipping, Inc. Petitioner, Vs. L. Acuario Marketing Corp. and Skyland Brokerage, Inc., Respondents.
  42. 42G.r. No. 147192 Government Service Insurance System, Petitioner, Vs. the City Assessor of Iloilo City, the Register of Deeds of Iloilo City and Rosalina Francisco, Represented by Her Attorney-in-Fact, Salvador Paja I,[*] Respondents.
  43. 43G.r. No. 147477 Hermenegildo M. Trinidad, Petitioner, Vs. Estrella Acapulco, Respondent.
  44. 44G.r. No. 147881 Ronaldo Gesmundo, Reynaldo Gesmundo, Heirs of Rodolfo Gesmundo (Deceased) Namely: Zenaida del Rosario Gesmundo (Wife), Herminigilda, Belinda, Jayson, Arnulfo and Joan, All Surnamed Gesmundo, Represented by Belinda Gesmundo, as Attorney-in-Fact, and Heirs of Manuel Gesmundo Sr. (Deceased) Namely: Resurrecion Evangelista Gesmundo (Wife), Melanie, Mario and Manuel, Jr., All Surnamed Gesmundo, Represented by the Latter as Attorney-in-Fact of His Co-Heirs, Petitioners, Vs. Salome Sahagun Vda. de Gesmundo, Sanora Gesmundo, Felix Gesmundo, Jr., Lilia Gesmundo, Rodora Gesmundo, and Raul Gesmundo, Respondents.
  45. 45G.r. No. 147790 Genuino Ice Company, Inc. Petitioner, Vs. Alfonso S. Magpantay, Respondent.
  46. 46G.r. No. 148079 Teresita P. Buenaventura, Petitioner, Vs. People of the Philippines, Respondent.
  47. 47G.r. No. 149670 Millex Construction and Development Corporation, Petitioner, Vs. Citystate Insurance Corporation, Respondent.
  48. 48G.r. No. 153134 Banco Filipino Savings and Mortgage Bank, Petitioner, Vs. Antonio G. Diaz and Elsie B. Diaz, Respondents.
  49. 49G.r. No. 153414 Victoria G. Callangan, Petitioner, Vs. People of the Philippines,[*] Respondent.
  50. 50G.r. No. 156252 Coca-Cola Bottlers Philippines, Inc., Petitioner, Vs. City of Manila, Liberty M. Toledo – City Treasurer and Joseph Santiago – Chief, Licensing Division, Respondents.
  51. 51G.r. No. 156959 J/sr. Supt. Josue G. Engaño, Petitioner, Vs. Honorable Court of Appeals, Dilg Secretary Jose D. Lina, Jr., and Chief Supt. Arturo W. Alit, Respondents.
  52. 52G.r. No. 158589 Philip Morris, Inc., Benson & Hedges (Canada), Inc., and Fabriques de Tabac Reunies, S.a., (Now Known as Philip Morris Products S.a.), Petitioners, Vs. Fortune Tobacco Corporation, Respondent.
  53. 53G.r. No. 161893 Manila Electric Company, Petitioner, Vs. Hon. Lorna Navarro-Domingo, in Her Capacity as the Presiding Judge, Regional Trial Court, Branch 201, Las Piñas, and Carmencita B. Lota, Respondent.
  54. 54G.r. No. 164337 Vicente S. Cenzon, Petitioner, Vs. Hon. Salvador Abad Santos as Acting Presiding Judge, RTC of Makati City, Branch 143, Hon. Assistant City Prosecutor Andres Marcos in His Capacity as Public Prosecutor of the City Prosecutor'S Office of Makati City and Margarita C. Sia, Respondents.
  55. 55G.r. No. 164948 Diwata Ramos Landingin Petitioner, Vs. Republic of the Philippines, Respondent.
  56. 56G.r. No. 166382 Gloria Jean R. Chaves, Petitioner, Vs. National Labor Relations Commission, St. Bridget School and Sister Mary Tarcila Abaño, Rgs, Respondents.
  57. 57G.r. No. 167379 Primelink Properties and Development Corporation and Rafaelito W. Lopez, Petitioners, Vs. Ma. Clarita T. Lazatin-Magat, Jose Serafin T. Lazatin, Jaime Teodoro T. Lazatin and Jose Marcos T. Lazatin, Respondents.
  58. 58G.r. No. 167724 Bpi Family Savings Bank, Inc., Petitioner, Vs. Margarita Vda. de Coscolluela, Respondent.
  59. 59G.r. No. 168217 Joy Lee Recuerdo, Petitioner, Vs. People of the Philippines, Respondent.
  60. 60G.r. No. 168486 Noe S. Andaya, Petitioner, Vs. People of the Philippines, Respondent.
  61. 61A.m. No. P-06-2167 (Formerly Oca Ipi No. 04-2079-P) Judge Plenio B. dela Peña, Municipal Circuit Trial Court, Caibiran-Culaba, Biliran, Complainant, Vs. Rogelio a. Sia, Clerk of Court, Municipal Circuit Trial Court, Caibiran-Culaba, Biliran, Respondent.
  62. 62G.R. 156643Francisco Salvador B. Acejas III v. People of the Philippines Vladimir S. Hernandez Vs. People of the Philippines
  63. 63G.R. 164460Office of the Ombudsman, Represented by Hon. Simeon v. Marcelo Vs. Carmencita D. Coronel
  64. 64G.r. No. 109389 Manila Electric Company, Petitioner, Vs. Spouses Hua Kim Peng and Angelita Ramoran, Respondents.
  65. 65A.m. No. Rtj-05-1925 (a.m. Oca Ipi No. 00-989-Rtj) Grace F. Munsayac C. de Villa, Lily F. Munsayac- Sunga, and Roy Peter F. Munsayac, Complainants, Vs. Judge Antonio C. Reyes, Respondent. [a. M. No. Rtj-05-1926 (a.m. Oca Ipi No. 01-1248-Rtj)] Ramon K. Ilusorio, Complainant, Vs. Judge Antonio C. Reyes, RTC, Branch 61, Baguio City, Respondent. [a. M. No. Rtj-05-1927 (a.m. Oca Ipi No. 02-1435-Rtj)] Judge Ruben C. Ayson, Complainant, Vs. RTC Judges of Baguio City, Respondents. [a. M. No. Rtj-05-1928 (a.m. Oca Ipi No. 02-1485-Rtj)] Judge Clarence Villanueva, Complainant, Vs. Judge Ruben C. Ayson, Respondent. [a.m. No. Rtj-05-1929 (a.m. Oca Ipi No. 02-1552-Rtj)] Judge Ruben C. Ayson, Complainant, Vs. Judge Abraham Borreta, Respondent. [a. M. No. Rtj-05-1930 (a.m. Oca Ipi No. 02-1559-Rtj)] Atty. Cristeta R. Caluza-Flores, Complainant, Vs. Judge Amado S. Caguioa, Respondent. [a. M. No. P-05-2020 (a.m. Oca Ipi No. 02-1358-P)] Hon. Amado S. Caguioa Complainant, Vs. Atty. Cristeta R. Caluza-Flores, Respondent.
  66. 66G.r. No. 159149 the Honorable Secretary Vincent S. Perez, in His Capacity as the Secretary of the Department of Energy, Petitioner, Vs. Lpg Refillers Association of the Philippines, Inc., Respondent.
  67. 67A.m. No. P-03-1678 Spouses Errol and Teresita Pan, Complainants, Vs. Albert S. Salamat, Sheriff IV, Regional Trial Court, Branch 80, Malolos, Bulacan, Respondent.
  68. 68G.r. No. 159314 Edgardo v. Estarija, Petitioner, Vs. Edward F. Ranada and the Honorable Ombudsman Aniano a. Desierto (Now Succeeded by Hon. Simeon Marcelo), and His Deputy Ombudsman for Mindanao, Hon. Antonio E. Valenzuela, Respondents.
  69. 69A.m. No. P-06-2140 (Formerly Oca I.p.i No. 06-2-51-Mtcc) Re: Report on the Financial Audit Conducted in the Mtcc-Occ, Angeles City.
  70. 70G.r. No. 124086 Godofredo S. Sison, in His Capacity as Deputy Administrator, Social Security System, Petitioner, Vs. Court of Appeals and Dr. Concepcion O. Lim-Tan, Respondents.
  71. 71G.r. No. 139897 Severina Rodrigo, Spouses Arnaldo Sauza and Francisca Carpentero, Spouses Alejandra Sauza and Rodolfo Limbaring, Camilo Sauza, Felimon Sauza,[1] Jr., Jose O. Fabriga and Cruz a. Limbaring, Petitioners, Vs. Sister Lucia Ancilla (Nee Esperanza Daomilas), Respondent.
  72. 72G.r. No. 142941 National Trucking and Forwarding Corporation, Petitioner, Vs. Right Forwarders Corporation, Solomon Shauf, Roberto Pagotan and Shirley Cruz Pagotan,[*] Respondents.
  73. 73G.r. No. 144635 Programme Incorporated, Petitioner, Vs. Province of Bataan,[1] Respondent.
  74. 74G.r. No. 144640 Rodolfo Tigoy, Petitioner, Vs. Court of Appeals and People of the Philippines, Respondents.
  75. 75G.r. No. 147375 Commissioner of Internal Revenue, Petitioner, Vs. Bank of the Philippine Islands, Respondent.
  76. 76G.r. No. 148512 Commissioner of Internal Revenue, Petitioner, Vs. Central Luzon Drug Corporation, Respondent.
  77. 77G.r. No. 149195 La Campana Development Corporation (Formerly La Campana Food Products, Inc.), Petitioner, Vs. Lalaine See, Henry So, Ricardo y. Ko, Omario Lingan, Reyman Lim, Michael Delimios, Leticia C. Hui, Chen Jiang, a.k.a. Sonny Tan, Jover Yu Chua, Jordan Yu Chua, .emerson Go Tian, Gregorio Ng Que, Herrick Filter Mfg. Corp., Chun Un Tian, New Lord Food Products, Inc., Paulino Li, Lite International Trading Corp. and Oriental Aluminum & Zinc Die Casting Corporation, Respondents.
  78. 78G.r. No. 149226 Rudigario C. Gatmaitan, Petitioner, Vs. Dr. Ricardo B. Gonzales, Office of the Ombudsman and Court of Appeals, Respondents.
  79. 79G.r. No. 149353 Jocelyn B. Doles, Petitioner, Vs. Ma. Aura Tina Angeles, Respondent.
  80. 80G.r. No. 153794 Sergio Marzonia, Petitioner, Vs. People of the Philippines, Respondent.
  81. 81G.R. 160406Sps. Dolores Miranda Provost and Jean Provost v. the Court of Appeals and Sps. Victor Ramos and Fe a. Ramos
  82. 82G.r. No. 161694 Pepito Velasco, Petitioner, Vs. National Labor Relations Commission, Antonio Tayag, Ernesto Tayag and Rodolfo Tayag, Respondents.
  83. 83G.R. 166859Republic of the Philippines v. Sandiganbayan (First Division), Eduardo M. Cojuangco, Jr., Agricultural Consultancy Services, Inc., Archipelago Realty Corp., Balente Ranch, Inc., Black Stallon Ranch, Inc., Christensen Plantation Company, Discovery Realty Corp., Dream Pastures, Inc., Echo Ranch, Inc., Far East Ranch, Inc., Filsov Shipping Company, Inc., First United Transport, Inc., Habagat Realty Development, Inc., Kalawakan Resorts, Inc., Kaunlaran Agricultural Corp., Labayug Air Terminals, Inc., Landair International Marketing Corp., Lhl Cattle Corporation, Lucena Oil Factory, Inc., Meadow Lark Plantations, Inc., Metroplex Commodities, Inc., Misty Mountain Agricultural Corp., Northeast Contract Traders, Inc., Northern Carriers Corporation, Oceanside Maritime Enterprises, Inc., Oro Verde Services, Inc., Pastoral Farms, Inc., Pcy Oil Manufacturing Corp., Philippine Technologies, Inc., Primavera Farms, Inc., Punong-Bayan Housing Development Corp., Pura Electric Company Inc., Radio Audience Developers Integrated Organization, Inc., Radyo Pilipino Corporation, Rancho Grande, Inc., Reddee Developers, Inc., San Esteban Development Corp., Silver Leaf Plantations, Inc., Southern Service Traders, Inc., Southern Star Cattle Corp., Spade One Resorts Corp., Unexplored Land Developers, Inc., Verdant Plantatations, Inc., Vesta Agricultural Corp. and Wings Resorts Corporation
  84. 84G.r. No. 167806 Phil Pharmawealth, Inc., Petitioner, Vs. Philippine Children'S Medical Center Bids and Awards Committee, Benjamin T. Lim, Emma a. Mariano, Nena U. Caldeo and Dahlia Carrios, Respondents.
  85. 85G.r. No. 166039 Digitel[*] Telecommunications Philippines, Inc., Johnson Robert L. Go[**] and Eric J. Severino,[***] Petitioners, Vs. Mariquit Soriano, Respondent.
  86. 86G.r. No. 169973 Placewell International Services Corporation, Petitioner, Vs. Ireneo B. Camote, Respondent.
  87. 87G.r. No. 152613 & 152628 Apex Mining Co., Inc., Petitioner, Vs. Southeast Mindanao Gold Mining Corp., the Mines Adjudication Board, Provincial Mining Regulatory Board (Pmrb-Davao), Monkayo Integrated Small Scale Miners Association, Inc., Rosendo Villaflor, Balite Communal Portal Mining Cooperative, Davao United Miners Cooperative, Antonio Dacudao, Puting-Bato Gold Miners Cooperative, Romeo Altamera, Thelma Catapang, Luis Galang, Renato Basmillo, Francisco Yobido, Eduardo Gloria, Edwin Asion, Macario Hernandez, Reynaldo Carubio, Roberto Buniales, Rudy Esportono, Romeo Castillo, Jose Rea, Gil Ganado, Primitiva Licayan, Leticia Alqueza and Joel Brillantes Management Mining Corporation, Respondents. [g.r. No. 152619-20] Balite Communal Portal Mining Cooperative, Petitioner, Vs. Southeast Mindanao Gold Mining Corp., Apex Mining Co., Inc., the Mines Adjudication Board, Provincial Mining Regulatory Board (Pmrb-Davao), Monkayo Integrated Small Scale Miners Association, Inc., Rosendo Villaflor, Davao United Miners Cooperative, Antonio Dacudao, Puting-Bato Gold Miners Cooperative, Romeo Altamera, Thelma Catapang, Luis Galang, Renato Basmillo, Francisco Yobido, Eduardo Gloria, Edwin Asion, Macario Hernandez, Reynaldo Carubio, Roberto Buniales, Rudy Esportono, Romeo Castillo, Jose Rea, Gil Ganado, Primitiva Licayan, Leticia Alqueza and Joel Brillantes Management Mining Corporation, Respondents. [g.r. No. 152870-71] the Mines Adjudication Board and Its Members, the Hon. Victor O. Ramos (Chairman), Undersecretary Virgilio Marcelo (Member) and Director Horacio Ramos (Member), Petitioners, Vs. Southeast Mindanao Gold Mining Corporation, Respondent.
  88. 88G.r. No. 169106 Datu Israel Sinsuat and Datu Jaberael Sinsuat, Petitioners, Vs. the Honorable Commission on Elections and the Special Municipal Board of Canvassers of South Upi, Maguindanao, as Public Respondents, Antonio Gunsi, Sr. & Jovito Martin, Abdullah Campong, Roland Moendeg, Ricarte Betita & Ariston Catalino, and Elinda Erese, Maria Sargan, Lydia Aron, Bienvenido Yap, Sr., Rodrigo Toriales, Warlito Pinuela, Vicente Betita, Jaime Usman, All as Private Respondents, Respondents.
  89. 89G.r. No. 147749 San Pablo Manufacturing Corporation, Petitioner, Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue,[*] Respondent.
  90. 90A.m. No. P-02-1651 (Formerly Oca I.p.i No. 00-1021-P) Alejandro Estrada, Complainant, Vs. Soledad S. Escritor, Respondent.
  91. 91G.r. No. 141212 Benguet Corporation, Petitioner, Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, Respondent.
  92. 92G.r. No. 141818 Insular Savings Bank, Petitioner, Vs. Far East Bank and Trust Company, Respondent.
  93. 93G.r. No. 142299 Bicolandia Drug Corporation (Formerly Elmas Drug Coproration), Petitioner, Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, Respondent.
  94. 94G.r. No. 143419 Jose B. del Rosario, Jr., Petitioner, Vs. the People of the Philippines and the Office of the Special Prosecutor,[*] Respondents.
  95. 95G.r. No. 149493 Rafaelito M. Garayblas, Petitioner, Vs. Jose L. Atienza, Jr., Mayor of the City of Manila, Atty. Emmanuel Sison, Secretary to the Mayor, Manila; Chairman and Members of the Board of Regents, Pamantasan Ng Lungsod Ng Maynila (Plm), Namely: Dr. Alejandro Roces, Atty. Raul I. Goco, Mr. Alfredo G. Gabot, Atty. Aguinaldo L. Miravalles and Paraluman R. Giron, Atty. Marites Barrios, Legal Officer v and Concurrently Secretary of the University and to the Board of Regents, Plm; Ms. Angelita Solis, Vice-President for Finance, Plm and Resident Auditor, Plm, Respondents.
  96. 96G.r. No. 151132 First Bancorp, Inc., Petitioner, Vs. Honorable Court of Appeals and Jane Thomas Lightner, Respondents.
  97. 97G.r. No. 155395 in Re: Petition for Cancellation of the Union Registration of Air Philippines Flight Attendants Association, Air Philippines Corporation, Petitioners, Vs. Bureau of Labor Relations and Air Philippines Flight Attendants Association, Respondents.
  98. 98G.r. No. 156503 Camilo P. Cabili, as Chairman of the Board of Trustees and Antonio R. de Vera, as Administrator, Local Water Utilities Administration (Lwua), Petitioners, Vs. Civil Service Commission (CSC) and Lwua Employees Association for Progress, Represented by Its Chairman, Leonardo C. Cruz, Respondents. [g.r. No. 156481] Civil Service Commission (CSC), Petitioner, Vs. Camilo P. Cabili, as Chairman of the Board of Trustees and Antonio R. de Vera, as Administrator, Local Water Utilities Administration (Lwua), Respondents.
  99. 99G.r. No. 161647 Leoncio S. Solidum, Petitioner, Vs. Court of Appeals (Fifteenth Division) and Insular Life Assurance Co. Ltd., Respondents.
  100. 100G.r. No. 163766 Republic of the Philippines, Petitioner, Vs. Candy Maker, Inc., as Represented by Its President, Ong Yee See,[*] Respondent
  101. 101G.r. No. 165853 Rosana Ereña, Petitioner, Vs. Vida Dana Querrer-Kauffman, Respondent.
  102. 102G.r. No. 167399 Ernestina L. Crisologo-Jose, Petitioner, Vs. Land Bank of the Philippines, Respondent.
  103. 103G.r. No. 168396 Marcelina v. Espino, for Herself and in Representation of Her Deceased Mother, Emerenciana v. Espino, and Spouses Felipe de Los Santos and Marissa de Los Santos, Petitioners, Vs. Spouses Ricardo Vicente and Emma M. Vicente, Respondents.
  104. 104G.r. No. 169213 Ganie P. Olama, Datu Makay S. Banto, Darimbang Antal Sultan, Camad Sangcopan, Jamil Abiden Tampugao, and Abdulgafor Angindarat, Petitioners, Vs. Philippine National Bank, Represented by Its Branch Manager at Marawi City, Madame Bai Sandorie Tampi Disomangcop and Land Bank of the Philippines, Represented by Its Branch Manager, Maclaring Lucman, Respondents. Abol M. Salim, Mustapha Buat, Elias R. Ditucalan, Jalil Abiden, Jamaloden G. Diator and Bato Adam, Intervenors-Respondents. Vs. Taha C. Ali, Third-Party Defendant.
  105. 105G.R. 147561Stronghold Insurance Company, Inc. v. Republic-Asahi Glass Corporation
  106. 106A.m. No. Rtj-06-1972 (Formerly Oca Ipi No. 05-2247-Rtj) John Panaligan, Complainant, Vs. Judge Francisco B. Ibay, Regional Trial Court, Branch 135, Makati City, Respondent.
  107. 107G.r. No. 143154 Advanced Foundation Construction Systems Corporation, Petitioner, Vs. New World Properties and Ventures, Inc., Respondent. [g.r. No. 143177] New World Properties and Ventures, Inc., Petitioner. Vs. Advanced Foundation Construction Systems Corporation, Respondent.
  108. 108G.r. No. 152347 Union Bank of the Philippines, Petitioner, Vs. Sps. Alfredo Ong and Susana Ong and Jackson Lee, Respondents.
  109. 109A.M. P-06-2150Prosecutor Laura E. Mabini v. Eustacio Raga, Legal Researcher, and Lilia Carnacete-Raga, Process Server, Regional Trial Court, Catbalogan, Samar, Branch 27 and Branch 28
  110. 110G.R. 158190-91Nissan Motors Philippines, Inc.vs. Secretary of Labor and Employment and Bagong Nagkakaisang Lakas Sa Nissan Motor Philippines, Inc. (Banal-Nmpi-Olalia-Kmu) Bagong Nagkakaisang Lakas Sa Nissan Motors Philippines, Inc. (Banal-Nmpi-Olalia-Kmu) v. Court of Appeals (Special Division of Five), Secretary of Labor and Employment and Nissan Motors Philippines, Inc
  111. 111G.r. No. 157491 Sps. Proceso Amurao and Minerva Amurao, Petitioners, Vs. Sps. Jacinto Villalobos and Herminigilda Villalobos, Respondents.
  112. 112A.m. No. P-04-1816 (Formerly Oca-Ipi No. 03-1747-P) Eusebio M. Baron, Complainant, Vs. Emiladie T. Anacan, Court Stenographer III, RTC-Branch 45, San Jose Occidental Mindoro, Respondent.
  113. 113G.R. 127857Pastor de Jesus v. Honorable Court of Appeals, Ronaldo, Alicia, Florante, Nelson, Bellaflor, Mario, Arnolfo, Jocelyn and Godfrey, All Surnamed de Jesus, All Represented by Ronaldo de Jesus
  114. 114G.r. No. 128464 Rev. Luis Ao-as, Rev. Jose Laking, Eusquicio Galang, Rev. Isabelo Mononggit, Rev. Edwino Mercado, Rev. Daniel Pondevida, Rev. Teodorico Taran and Dr. Benjamin Galapia, Petitioners, Vs. Hon. Court of Appeals, Thomas P. Batong, Juanito Basalong, Augusto Catangi, Paul Garcia, Quido Rivera, Victorio y. Saquilayan and Danilo Zamora, Respondents.
  115. 115G.r. No. 146547 Villa Macasasa and Gertrudes Lanutan, Petitioners, Vs. Juanita Sicad and Ernesto Macasasa, Respondents.
  116. 116G.r. No. 147524 Segundo S. Lim, Petitioner, Vs. Court of Appeals, Hon. Simeon P. Dumdum, Jr., Presiding Judge, Regional Trial Court, Branch 7, Cebu City, the People of the Philippines, and Cirse "Choy" Torralba, Respondents.
  117. 117G.r. No. 148630 Angelo Dwight Penson, Petitioner, Vs. Spouses Melchor and Virginia Maranan, Respondents.
  118. 118G.r. No. 151890 Prudential Guarantee and Assurance Inc., Petitioner, Vs. Trans-Asia Shipping Lines, Inc., Respondent. [g.r. No. 151991] Trans-Asia Shipping Lines, Inc., Petitioner, Vs. Prudential Guarantee and Assurance Inc., Respondent.
  119. 119G.r. No. 157194 Antonio P. Tan, Petitioner, Vs. Hon. Court of Appeals (Special Former Fourth Division), the Honorable Wilfredo D. Reyes, Acting Presiding Judge, Regional Trial Court, Branch 31, Manila, the Register of Deeds of Manila and Dpg Development & Management Corporation, Respondents.
  120. 120G.r. No. 157671 Danilo G. Punongbayan, Petitioner, Vs. Perfecto G. Punongbayan, Jr., Marilou P. Visitacion, and Sotero a. Punongbayan, Respondents.
  121. 121G.r. No. 157804 Cerilo Bricenio, Petitioner, Vs. People of the Philippines, Respondent.
  122. 122G.r. No. 166139 Republic of the Philippines, Petitioner, Vs. Pedro T. Casimiro, Respondent.
  123. 123G.r. No. 170702 Ingatun G. Istarul, Petitioner, Vs. Commission on Elections and Pamaran T. Maturan, Respondents.
  124. 124A.c. No. 6288 Marili C. Ronquillo, Alexander Ronquillo and Jon Alexander Ronquillo, Represented by Their Attorney-in-Fact Servillano a. Cabungcal, Complainants, Vs. Atty. Homobono T. Cezar, Respondent.
  125. 125G.r. No. 164147 Agustin Vitalista, Orlando Vitalista, Leonardo Vitalista, Aurelio Vitalista, Lazaro Vitalista, Pedro Mempin, and Enrique dela Cruz, Petitioners, Vs. Florentino Bantigue Perez, Jose Bantigue Perez, Jacinto Bantigue Perez, Ernesto Bantigue Perez, Felicisima Bantigue Perez, Belen Bantigue Perez, and Joselito Perez Tuano Respondents.
  126. 126G.r. Nos. 168188-89 People of the Philippines, Petitioner, Vs. Sandiganbayan (First Division), Dominador T. Belac, Noe v. Dannang, Juan M. Boguen and Thomas B. Tubban, Jr., Respondents.
  127. 127G.r. No. 146726 Multi-Realty Development Corporation, Petitioner, Vs. the Makati Tuscany Condominium Corporation, Respondent.
  128. 128G.r. No. 154430 Sps. Jose N. Binarao and Preciosisima Binarao, Petitioners, Vs. Plus Builders, Inc., Respondent.
  129. 129G.r. No. 148130 Petroleum Shipping Limited (Formerly Esso International Shipping (Bahamas) Co., Ltd.) and Trans-Global Maritime Agency, Inc., Petitioners, Vs. National Labor Relations Commission and Florello W. Tanchico, Respondents.
  130. 130G.r. No. 157286 the Public Schools District Supervisors Association (Psdsa), Its Officers, to Wit: Dr. Anilla a. Calamba, President; Dr. Carmelita L. Palabay, Gen. Vice-President; Ms. Estelita R. Reyes, Board Secretary; Dr. Thelma a. Galang, Asst. Board Secretary; Mr. Fernando Lavita, Treasurer; Ms. Lita Dionisio, Asst. Treasurer; Ms. Roselily Padre, Auditor; Mr. Roman Calicdan, Asst. Auditor; Mr. Tomo-Ay, Mr. Oscar Peñaflorida, Bus. Managers; Dr. Antonette Ang, Dr. Magnita Labrador, P.r.o.'S; Mr. Bonifacio Miguel (Region I), Mr. Jose Calagui (Region II), Dr. Reynaldo Sagum (Region III), Mr. Ruben Panahon (Region IV), Mr. Oscar Barba (Region v), Ms. Irma Ganela (Region Vi), Dr. Erlinda Napuli (Region Vii), Dr. Ponciano Gabieta (Region Viii), Mr. Federico Fidel (Region Ix), Mr. Emiliano v. Rodriguez (Region X), Ms. Edwina Alag (Region Xi), Mr. Dominador Atam (Region Xii), Ms. Consuelo Velasco (Ncr), Mr. Victorino Agmata (Car), Ms. Natividad Salasab (Armm-Caraga), All Psdsa Vice-Presidents for Their Respective Regions: Dr. Lolita Cabanayan, Mr. Cicero Aklang, Dr. Rustico Ocampo, Mr. Romeo Santos, Mr. Emmanuel Cama, Mr. Romeo Tumaob, Mr. Jovencio Mendoza, Mr. Alejandro Baring, Jr., Ms. Bernardita Apostol, Ms. Loreta Macaludas, Dr. Myrna Lyn Maracon, Ms. Elizabeth San Diego, Sith Hindron Dammang, Ms. Immaculada Bringas, and Ms. Gloria Derecho, All Members of the Psdsa Board of Directors, in Their Own Behalf as Current District Supervisors and in Representation of All District Supervisors of the Department of Education, Petitioners, Vs. Hon. Edilberto C. de Jesus, Department Secretary, the Department of Education, and the Department of Budget and Management, Respondents.
  131. 131G.r. No. 160675 Office of the Ombudsman, Petitioner, Vs. Court of Appeals (Sixteenth Division) and Nicomedes Armilla, Delia Batasin-in, James Fuentes, Oscar Gador, Santos Guigayoma,jr., Clarito Miñoza, Ernesto Naraja, Nelson Obeso,[*] Senen Seriño, and Martin Yase, Respondents.
  132. 132G.R. 163655Inocencio Alimboboyog v. Hon. Court of Appeals and Paz Noble-Noblefranca
  133. 133G.r. No. 165734 Atty. Ramon B. Ceniza, Petitioner, Vs. Daniel Wistehuff, Sr., Daniel Wistehuff III, Marites Gonzales-Wistehuff, Bryan K. Wistehuff, Atty. Francis M. Zosa, and Gemalyn Peteros, Respondents.
  134. 134G.r. No. 165827 National Power Corporation, Petitioner, Vs. Province of Isabela, Represented by Hon. Benjamin G. Dy, Provincial Governor, Respondent.
  135. 135G.r. No. 168498 Rizal Commercial Banking Corporation, Petitioner, Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, Respondent.
  136. 136G.r. No. 168990 Teresita S. Barranco, Petitioner, Vs. Commission on the Settlement of Land Problems, Respondent.
  137. 137G.r. No. 169299 Eastern Telecommunications Phils., Inc., Petitioner, Vs. Maria Charina Diamse, Respondent.
  138. 138G.r. No. 169476 Douglas Lu Ym, Petitioner, Vs. Atty. Makilito B. Mahinay & Hon. Judge Olegario Sarmiento, Jr., Respondents.
  139. 139G.r. No. 169509 Jocelyn E. Cabo, Petitioner, Vs. the Sandiganbayan, Fourth Division, the Special Prosecutor of the Ombudsman and the Commission on Audit, Region Xiii, Respondents.
  140. 140G.r. No. 170474 People of the Philippines, Appellee, Vs. Alex Candaza y Calvadores, Appellant.
  141. 141G.R. 152640Department of Agrarian Reform, Rep. by Secretary Hernani a. Braganza v. Philippine Communications Satellite Corp
  142. 142G.r. No. 149379 Philippine Long Distance Telephone Company, Inc., Petitioner, Vs. Homer Imperial, Respondent.
  143. 143G.r. No. 138145 Suico Rattan & Buri Interiors, Inc. and Spouses Esmeraldo and Elizabeth D. Suico, Petitioners, Vs. Court of Appeals and Metropolitan Bank and Trust Co., Inc., Respondents.
  144. 144A.m. No. P-06-2171 [formerly Oca Ipi No. 03-1661-P] Leilani E. Nacionales, Complainant, Vs. Sheryll S. Madlangbayan, Clerk III, Regional Trial Court, Mandaluyong City, Branch 210, Respondent.
  145. 145G.r. No. 146523 Spouses Aniceto and Thelma Cirelos, Petitioners, Vs. Spouses William G. Hernandez, and Rosemarie Zafe and the Hon. Court of Appeals, Respondents.
  146. 146G.r. No. 148320 Pilipinas Bank, Petitioner, Vs. Glee Chemical Laboratories, Inc., Respondent.
  147. 147G.R. 167118Manila Memorial Park Cemetery, Inc. and/or Enrique B. Lagdameo v. Delia v. Panado
  148. 148A.c. No. 5303 Humberto C. Lim, Jr., in Behalf of Penta Resorts Corporation/attorney-in-Fact of Lumot a. Jalandoni, Complainant, Vs. Atty. Nicanor v. Villarosa, Respondent.
  149. 149A.c. No. 5377 Victor Lingan, Complainant, Vs. Attys. Romeo Calubaquib and Jimmy P. Baliga, Respondents.
  150. 150A.m. No. Rtj-06-1969 (Formerly Oca Ipi No. 05-2159-Rtj) Atty. Hugolino v. Balayon, Jr., Complainant, Vs. Judge Oscar E. Dinopol, Regional Trial Court, Branch 24, Koronadal City, Respondent.
  151. 151G.r. No. 142535 Carme Caspe, Petitioner, Vs. Court of Appeals and Susan S. Vasquez, Respondents.
  152. 152G.r. No. 144026 Fernando S. Dizon, Petitioner, Vs. People of the Philippines, Respondent.
  153. 153G.r. No. 146007 Pepsico, Inc., Now Known as the Pepsi Cola Company, Petitioner, Vs. Jaime Lacanilao, Respondent. [g.r. No. 146295] Pepsi-Cola Products Phils., Inc., Petitioner, Vs. Court of Appeals and Jaime Lacanilao, Respondents.
  154. 154G.r. No. 146824 Encarnacion E. Santiago, Petitioner, Vs. Commission on Audit and the Director of the Commission on Audit, Regional Office No. v, Respondents.
  155. 155G.r. No. 152459 Emelita Leonardo, Conrado Bargamento, Emelita Nuñez, Rodolfo Graban, and Roberto Graban, Petitioners, Vs. Court of Appeals and Digital Telecommunications Philippines, Inc., Respondents.
  156. 156G.r. No. 152551 General Bank and Trust Company, Petitioner, Vs. Central Bank of the Philippines and Arnulfo B. Aurellano in His Capacity as Liquidator of General Bank and Trust Company, Respondents.
  157. 157G.r. No. 156253 Carlos R. Gonzales, Petitioner, Vs. Civil Service Commission and Philippine Amusement and Gaming Corporation,[**] Respondents.
  158. 158G.r. No. 169026 First Women'S Credit Corporation and Shig Katayama, Petitioners, Vs. Hon. Hernando B. Perez, in His Capacity as the Secretary of the Department of Justice, Ramon P. Jacinto, Jaime C. Colayco, Antonio P. Tayao, and Glicerio Perez, Respondents.
  159. 159G.r. No. 172556 Trans Middle East (Phils.), Petitioner, Vs. Sandiganbayan (5th Division) Presidential Commission on Good Government (Pcgg), the Board of Directors of Equitable Pci Bank, Represented by Its Chairman, Corazon dela Paz and Sabino Acut, Jr. (in His Capacity as Corporate Secretary of Equitable Pci Bank), Respondents.
  160. 160G.r. No. 158793 James Mirasol, Richard Santiago, and Luzon Motorcyclists Federation, Inc., Petitioners, Vs. Department of Public Works and Highways and Toll Regulatory Board, Respondents.
  161. 161G.r. No. 166239 Elsie Ang, Petitioner, Vs. Dr. Erniefel Grageda, Respondent.
  162. 162G.r. No. 146459 Heirs of Dicman, Namely: Ernesto Dicman, Paul Dicman, Florence Dicman Feliciano Torres, Emily Torres, Tomasito Torres and Heirs of Cristina Alawas and Babing Cosil, Petitioners, Vs. Jose Cariño and Court of Appeals, Respondents.
  163. 163A.m. No. Mtj-05-1605 (Formerly Oca Ipi No. 05-1690-Mtj) Pedro C. Abesa, Complainant, Vs. Judge Jose P. Nacional, Municipal Trial Court, Branch 1, Naga City, Respondent.
  164. 164G.r. No. 125684 Alejo Aranda, Simeona Joson-Aranda, Bonifacia Aranda, Pelagia Aranda, Dominador Aranda,vivencio Aranda, Lolita Aranda, Jeffrey Aranda, and Feliciano Aranda, Petitioners, Vs. Fortune Savings & Loan Association, Inc., the Provincial Sheriff of Cavite, Sabrino C. Aranda, Veronica Aranda, the Register of Deeds of the Province of Cavite and the Honorable Court of Appeals, Respondents.
  165. 165G.r. No. 131614 Intestate Estate of the Late Felipe Buenaventura, Anacoreta B. Francisco, Judicial Administratrix-Petitioner, Vs. Ilog Agricultural Corporation, Intervenor, Nicasia Buenaventura, Heir-Respondent.
  166. 166G.r. No. 136051 Alfredo P. Rosete, Oscar P. Mapalo and Chito P. Rosete, Petitioners, Vs. Juliano Lim and Lilia Lim, Respondents.
  167. 167G.r. No. 139868 Alonzo Q. Ancheta, Petitioner, Vs. Candelaria Guersey-Dalaygon, Respondent.
  168. 168G.r. No. 141637 Romy'S Freight Service, Represented by Roman G. Cruz, Petitioner, Vs. Jesus C. Castro, Dominador Veloria and the First Division of the Court of Appeals, Respondents.
  169. 169G.r. No. 142731 Bank of the Philippine Islands (Formerly Far East Bank and Trust Company), Petitioner, Vs. Court of Appeals and Jimmy T. Go, Respondents.
  170. 170G.r. No. 143542 Sime Darby Pilipinas, Inc. and Larry C. Dubberly, Petitioners, Vs. Alfredo Arguilla and Henry C. Pedrajas, Respondents.
  171. 171G.r. No. 144805 Eduardo v. Lintonjua, Jr. and Antonio K. Litonjua, Petitioners, Vs. Eternit Corporation (Now Eterton Multi- Resources Corporation), Eteroutremer, S.a. and Far East Bank & Trust Company, Respondents.
  172. 172G.r. No. 145209 Lydio Alvero, Petitioner, Vs. People of the Philippines, Respondent.
  173. 173G.r. No. 146933 Spouses Constantino Espiridion and Remedios Espiridion and Spouses Renato Ramos and Erlinda Ramos, Petitioners, Vs. Court of Appeals and Second Bulacan Development Bank, Respondents.
  174. 174G.r. No. 147464 Josefina Teotico (Also Known as Baby Santana), Petitioner, Vs. Rosario D. Baer, Respondent.
  175. 175G.r. No. 147839 Gaisano Cagayan, Inc. Petitioner, Vs. Insurance Company of North America, Respondent.
  176. 176G.r. No. 148759 Germelina Torres Racaza and Bernaldita Torres Paras, Petitioners, Vs. Ernesto Gozum, Respondent.
  177. 177G.r. No. 160191 Twin Ace Holdings Corporation, Petitioner, Vs. Rufina and Company, Respondent.
  178. 178G.r. No. 164772 Equitable Banking Corporation (Now Known as Equitable-Pci Bank), Petitioner, Vs. Ricardo Sadac, Respondent.
  179. 179G.r. No. 166751 Ridgewood Estate, Inc. (Erroneously Sued as Camella Homes), Petitioner, Vs. Expedito Belaos, Respondent.