April 2005

121decisions
  1. 01A.M. P-03-1755Judge Manuel S. Sollesta v. Salvacion B. Mission
  2. 02A.M. RTJ-05-1896Atty. Julius Neri v. Judge Jesus S. de La Peña
  3. 03G.r. No. 128392 Cesar Mateo, Candido Mateo, Domingo a. Santos, Danilo Rivera Virginia Jardin Gupit, Zenaida Aranda, et al., Petitioners, Vs. Court of Appeals and Casimiro Development Corporation, Respondents.
  4. 04G.r. No. 132209 Carlos C. Buendia, Petitioner, Vs. City of Iligan, Respondent.
  5. 05G.r. No. 147632 Rey Geal, Petitioner, Vs. Emma Geal, Respondent.
  6. 06G.r. No. 148323 Bernandino S. Manioso, Petitioner, Vs. Government Service Insurance System, Respondent.
  7. 07G.r. No. 152324 Land Bank of the Philippines, Petitioner, Vs. Hon. Pepito Planta, in His Capacity as Provincial Adjudicator of the Department of Agrarian Reform Adjudication Board (Darab), and Faustino B. Tobia, Respondents.
  8. 08G.r. No. 155037 Anvil Ensembles Garment, Petitioner, Vs. Court of Appeals (Former Seventeenth Division), National Labor Relations Commission (Second Division), Hon. Cresencio Ramos, Jr., in His Capacity as Labor Arbiter, and Melecio Bonabon, Respondents.
  9. 09G.r. No. 155059 American Wire and Cable Daily Rated Employees Union, Petitioner, Vs. American Wire and Cable Co., Inc. and the Court of Appeals, Respondents.
  10. 10G.r. No. 155207 Wilhelmina S. Orozco, Petitioner, Vs. the Fifth Division of the Honorable Court of Appeals, Philippine Daily Inquirer, and Leticia Jimenez Magsanoc, Respondents.
  11. 11G.r. No. 155478 Spouses Guillermo and Andylynn Hizo, Petitioners, Vs. Court of Appeals and Sammie Bacorro, Represented by Attorney-in-Fact Benilda Bacorro, Respondents.
  12. 12G.r. No. 157146 Laguna Autoparts Manufacturing Corporation, Petitioner, Vs. Office of the Secretary, Department of Labor and Employment (DOLE) and Laguna Autoparts Manufacturing Corporation Obrero Pilipino-Lamcor Chapter, Respondents.
  13. 13G.r. No. 159145 Department of Agrarian Reform Adjudication Board (Darab) of the Department of Agrarian Reform (Dar), Represented by Dar Secretary Roberto M. Pagdanganan, Petitioner, Vs. Josefina S. Lubrica, in Her Capacity as Assignee of the Rights and Interest of Federico Suntay, Respondent.
  14. 14G.r. No. 158758 P.j. Lhuillier Inc. and Philippe J. Lhuillier, Petitioners, Vs. National Labor Relations Commission and Herminia Montenegro, Respondents.
  15. 15G.r. No. 160384 Cesar T. Hilario, for Himself and as Attorney-in-Fact of Ibarra, Nestor, Lina and Prescilla, All Surnamed Hilario, Petitioners, Vs. Allan T. Salvador, Respondent. Heirs of Salustiano Salvador, Namely, Regidor M. Salvador and Virginia Salvador-Lim, Respondents-Intervenors.
  16. 16G.r. No. 150736 Virgilio Macaspac, Petitioner, Vs. Ruperto Puyat, Jr., Respondent.
  17. 17G.r. No. 151827 Josefina Benares, Petitioner, Vs. Jaime Pancho, Rodolfo Pancho, Jr., Joselito Medalla, Paquito Magallanes, Alicia Magallanes, Evelyn Magallanes, Violeta Villacampa, Maritess Pancho, Rogelio Pancho and Arnolfo Pancho, Respondents.
  18. 18G.r. No. 148470 Lopez dela Rosa Development Corporation and Gloria dela Rosa Lopez, Petitioners, Vs. Hon. Court of Appeals, National Labor Relations Commission, Labor Arbiter Vicente Layawen and Ariel Chavez, Respondents.
  19. 19G.r. No. 157447 Nemencio C. Evangelista, Pascual G. Quinto, Luis B. Buena, Eusebia v. Tablada, Canuto G. Tisbe, David R. Carullo, Sofonias E. Colegado, Felix B. Buena, Toribio C. Evangelista, Lebrada a. Nicolas, Alecia J. Ramos, Mila G. de Los Reyes, Salvador I. de La Torre, Moises Cruz, Rufino Infante, Alicia Astrologo, Trinidad Lumiqued, Luzminida Quiniquini, & Teodora C. Temeras, Petitioners, Vs. Carmelino M. Santiago, Respondent.
  20. 20G.r. No. 133709 Constante Siccuan, Petitioner, Vs. People of the Philippines, Respondent.
  21. 21G.r. No. 149252 Donald Kwok, Petitioner, Vs. Philippine Carpet Manufacturing Corporation, Respondent.
  22. 22G.r. No. 151857 Calamba Steel Center, Inc. (Formerly Js Steel Corporation), Petitioner, Vs. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, Respondent.
  23. 23G.r. No. 159922 Armando F. Chan, Petitioner, Vs. Court of Appeals, Hon. Simeon v. Marcelo, in His Capacity as Ombudsman, Antonio a. Odejerte, Borongan, Eastern Samar, Serafin v. Perez, Jr., David P. Adongay, Jr. and Virgilio G. Aleria – All From the Department of Public Works and Highways (Dpwh) Engineering District, Catarman, Northern Samar, Respondents.
  24. 24A.c. No. 1109 Maria Elena Moreno, Complainant, Vs. Atty. Ernesto Araneta, Respondent.
  25. 25A.C. 5365Spouses Franklin and Lourdes Olbes v. Atty. Victor v. Deciembre
  26. 26A.m. No. Mtj-00-1313 Virgilio P. Alconera, Complainant, Vs. Judge Jose S. Majaducon, Respondent.
  27. 27G.r. No. 155108 Republic of the Philippines, Represented by Department of Public Works and Highways (Dpwh) Under Secretary Simeon Datumanong and Undersecretary Edmundo v. Mir, Then Chairman of Bid and Awards Committee (Bac), Assistant Secretary Bashir D. Rasuman, Bac Vice-Chairman, Director Oscar D. Abundo, Bac Member Director Oic-Director Antonio v. Malano, Jr., Bac Member and Project Director Philip F. Menez, Petitioner, Vs. Emiliano R. Nolasco, Respondent.
  28. 28G.r. No. 157684 Department of Health, Petitioner, Vs. Priscilla G. Camposano, Enrique L. Perez, and Imelda Q. Agustin, Respondents.
  29. 29A.m. No. P-98-1281 Office of the Court Administrator, Complainant, Vs. Sylvia R. Yan, Stenographic Reporter and Former Oic, Respondent.
  30. 30A.m. No. 02-9-233-Mtcc in Re: Report on the Judicial and Financial Audit Conducted in the Municipal Trial Court in Cities, Koronadal City
  31. 31G.r. No. 145441 Philippine Savings Bank, Petitioner, Vs. Sps. Rodolfo C. Mañalac, Jr. and Rosita P. Mañalac, Respondents.
  32. 32G.r. No. 161904 Asian Construction and Development Corporation, Petitioner, Vs. Noel T. Tulabut, Doing Business Under the Name and Style of N.t. Tulabut Construction Supply, Respondent.
  33. 33A.m. No. 05-2-101-RTC Report on the Judicial Audit Conducted in the Regional Trial Court, Branch 8, Cebu City,
  34. 34A.m. No. Mtj-05-1589 (Formerly a.m. Oca Ipi No. 03-1454-Mtj) Zenaida J. Castro, Complainant, Vs. Judge Nicasio v. Bartolome, Municipal Trial Court, Sta. Maria, Bulacan, Respondent.
  35. 35A.m. No. P-05-1993 (Oca I.p.i. No. 04-1971-P) Vice-Executive Judge Divina Luz P. Aquino-Simbulan, Complainant, Vs. Edgardo a. Zabat, Sheriff IV, Regional Trial Court, San Fernando, Pampanga, Respondent.
  36. 36G.r. No. 109976 Philippine National Oil Company, Petitioner, Vs. the Hon. Court of Appeals, the Commissioner of Internal Revenue and Tirso Savellano, Respondents. G.r. No. 112800 Philippine National Bank, Petitioner, Vs. the Hon. Court of Appeals, Court of Tax Appeals, Tirso B. Savellano and Commissioner of Internal Revenue, Respondents.
  37. 37G.r. No. 128354 Home Bankers Savings & Trust Co., Petitioner, Vs. the Honorable Court of Appeals, Pablo N. Arevalo, Francisco a. Uy, Spouses Leandro a. Soriano, Jr. and Lilian Soriano, Alfredo Lim and Felisa Chi Lim/alfredo Lim, Respondents.
  38. 38G.r. No. 140301 Paul C. del Moral, Juan Antonio del Moral and Jose Luis C. del Moral, Petitioners, Vs. Republic of the Philippines Represented by the Presidential Commission on Good Government (Pcgg) and the Sandiganbayan, Respondent.
  39. 39G.r. No. 146997 Spouses Godofredo & Dominica Flancia, Petitioners, Vs. Court of Appeals & William Ong Genato, Respondents.
  40. 40G.r. No. 147080 Capitol Medical Center, Inc., Petitioner, Vs. National Labor Relations Commission, Jaime Ibabao, Jose Ballesteros, Ronald Centeno, Narciso Sarmiento, Eduardo Canaveral, Sherlito dela Cruz, Sofronio Comandao, Mariano Galicia, Ramon Molod, Carmencita Sarmiento, Helen Molod, Rosa Comandao, Angelito Cuizon, Alex Marasigan, Jesus Cedro, Enrico Roque, Jay Perilla, Helen Mendoza, Mary Gladys Gemperoso, Nini Bautista, Elena Macarubbo, Mustiola Salvacion Dapito, Alexander Manabe, Michael Eustaquio, Rose Azares, Fernando Manzano, Henry Vera Cruz, Chito Mendoza, Fredelita Tomayao, Isabel Brucal, Mahalko Layacan, Rainier Manacsa, Karen Villarente, Frances Acacio, Lamberto Conti, Lorena Beach, Judilah Ravalo, Deborah Nave, Marilen Cabalquinto, Emiliana Rivera, Ma. Rosario Urbano, Rowena Arilla, Capitol Medical Center Employees Association-Afw, Gregorio del Prado, Ariel Araja, and Jesus Sta. Barbara, Jr., Respondents.
  41. 41G.r. No. 156447 Juan Agas and Rustica Agas, Petitioners, Vs. Caridad Sabico, Respondent.
  42. 42G.r. No. 157718 Alvin Amployo y Ebalada, Petitioner, Vs. People of the Philippines, Respondent.
  43. 43G.r. Nos. 161784-86 Dinah C. Barriga, Petitioner, Vs. the Honorable Sandiganbayan (4th Division) and the People of the Philippines, Respondents.
  44. 44G.r. No. 156317 Carlos F. Salomon, Stephen L. Bathan, Nicolas E. Camara, Emmanuel B. dela Torre, Leonilo C. Donato, Segundo E. Ferrer, Jesus L. Guela, Jr., Amado P. Liongson, Deogracias C. Manalanzan, Gerundio a. Natanauan, Ricardo D. Parza, Ricardo R. Samaniego, Valentin R. Urrea, Jr., Francisco H. Villanueva, Petitioners, Vs. Associate of International Shipping Lines, Inc., Respondent.
  45. 45G.r. No. 150255 Schmitz Transport & Brokerage Corporation, Petitioner, Vs. Transport Venture, Inc., Industrial Insurance Company, Ltd., and Black Sea Shipping and Dodwell Now Inchcape Shipping Services, Respondents.
  46. 46A.c. No. 5655 Valeriana U. Dalisay, Complainant, Vs. Atty. Melanio Mauricio, Jr., Respondent.
  47. 47A.m. No. P-04-1866 (Formerly a.m. No. 04-6-336-RTC) Office of the Court Administrator, Complainant, Vs. Evacuato F. Balbona, Sheriff IV, Regional Trial Court, Branch 13, Cebu City, Respondent.
  48. 48G.r. No. 101487 Raul H. Sesbreño, Petitioner, Vs. Hon. Court of Appeals, Hon. Silvestre Bello III, Norberto Abellana, Ronald Arcilla, Demetrio Balicha, Felipe Constantino, Juan Coromina, Loreto Durano, Jesus Garcia, Jose Garcia, Vicente Garcia, Angelita Lhullier and Samuel Nuñez, Respondents.
  49. 49G.r. No. 146006 Jose C. Lee and Alma Aggabao, in Their Capacities as President and Corporate Secretary, Respectively, of Philippine International Life Insurance Company, and Filipino Loan Assistance Group, Petitioners, Vs. Regional Trial Court of Quezon City, Branch 85 Presided by Judge Pedro M. Areola, Branch Clerk of Court Janice y. Antero, Deputy Sheriffs Adenauer G. Rivera and Pedro L. Borja, All of the Regional Trial Court of Quezon City Branch 85, Ma. Divina Enderes Claiming to Be Special Administratrix, and Other Persons/public Officers Acting for and in Their Behalf, Respondents.
  50. 50G.r. No. 150255 Schmitz Transport & Brokerage Corporation, Petitioner, Vs. Transport Venture, Inc., Industrial Insurance Company, Ltd., and Black Sea Shipping and Dodwell Now Inchcape Shipping Services, Respondents.
  51. 51G.r. No. 156171 Spouses Ricardo and Ferma Portic, Petitioners, Vs. Anastacia Cristobal, Respondent.
  52. 52G.r. No. 157195 Vicar International Construction, Inc., and Carmelita v. Lim, Petitioners, Vs. Feb Leasing and Finance Corporation (Now Bpi Leasing Corporation), Respondent.
  53. 53G.r. No. 142030 Arturo Gallardo, Peter Melchor J. Arches, Allan B. Ampoloquio, Cirilo N. Bacquiano, Josue M. Rodaje, Benjamin R. Macasaet, Jr., Victorina Delos Cientos-Miral, Rodolfo M. Cartin, Quirina T. Sarte, Norberto E. Gomez, Genefredo P. Espina, Noel Guinita, and Ofelia Nacional, Petitioners, Vs. People of the Philippines, Sandiganbayan, Honorable Aniano Desierto in His Official Capacity as Ombudsman, and Office of the Special Prosecutor, Respondents.
  54. 54A.c. No. 6585 Tomas B. Yumol, Jr., Felix S. Ventic, Elmer L. Maniego and Jake M. Magcalas, Complainants, Vs. Atty. Roberto R. Ferrer, Sr., Respondent.
  55. 55A.m. No. Rtj-05-1910 (Formerly a.m. Oca Ipi No. 03-1904-Rtj) Alfredo Hilado, Lopez Sugar Corporation and First Farmers Holding Corporation, Complainants, Vs. Judge Amor a. Reyes Regional Trial Court of Manila, Branch 21, Respondent.
  56. 56A.c. No. 5835 Carlos B. Reyes, Complainant, Vs. Atty. Jeremias R. Vitan, Respondent.
  57. 57G.r. No. 159647 Commissioner of Internal Revenue, Petitioner, Vs. Central Luzon Drug Corporation, Respondent.
  58. 58A.m. No. Mtj-04-1547 (Formerly Oca Ipi No. 02-1256-Mtj) Josefina C. Ribaya, Complainant, Vs. Judge Aurora Binamira-Parcia, Municipal Trial Court in Cities, Ligao City, Respondent.
  59. 59A.c. No. 5864 Arturo L. Sicat, Complainant, Vs. Atty. Gregorio E. Ariola, Jr., Respondent.
  60. 60A.C. 6595Joseph Samala v. Atty. Antonuitti K. Palaña
  61. 61A.m. No. Mtj-05-1587 [formerly Ipi No. 04-1588-Mtj] Pilar Barredo-Fuentes, Lourdes J. Estrellado, Clarita Estrellado-Mainar, and Florenda Estrellado-Diaz, Complainants, Vs. Judge Romeo C. Albarracin, Mtcc, Branch 3, Davao City, Respondent.
  62. 62A.m. No. P-04-1927 (Formerly Oca Ipi No. 02-1319-P) Alicia Aradanas, Complainant, Vs. Catherine v. Dimaclid, Reggie O. Brigido, Riza L. Pelegrino*, Respondents.
  63. 63A.m. No. P-05-1986 (Formerly a.m. Oca Ipi No. 02-1522-P) Atty. Generoso Legaspi, Jr., Complainant, Vs. Atty. J. Rogelio T. Montero III, Clerk of Court, Municipal Trial Court in Cities, San Jose del Monte City, Bulacan, Respondent.
  64. 64G.r. No. 122904 Adoracion E. Cruz, Thelma Debbie E. Cruz, Gerry E. Cruz and Nerissa Cruz-Tamayo, Petitioners, Vs. the Honorable Court of Appeals, Summit Financing Corp., Victor S. Sta. Ana, Maximo C. Contreras, Ramon G. Manalastas, and Vicente Torres, Respondents.
  65. 65G.r. No. 130230 Metropolitan Manila Development Authority, Petitioner, Vs. Dante O. Garin, Respondent.
  66. 66G.r. No. 133638 Perpetua Vda. de Ape, Petitioner, Vs. the Honorable Court of Appeals and Genorosa Cawit Vda. de Lumayno, Respondents.
  67. 67G.r. No. 140495 G & M (Phils.), Inc., Petitioner, Vs. Epifanio Cruz, Respondent.
  68. 68G.r. Nos. 142286-87 Korea Exchange Bank, Petitioner, Vs. Hon. Rogelio C. Gonzales, in His Capacity as Presiding Judge of Branch 50 of the Regional Trial Court of Pampanga, Phi-Han Development, Inc., Lourdes de Mesa Mendoza, Meneleo Mendoza, Antusa de Mesa Magno, Francisco Magno, Teodoro de Mesa, Firmo de Mesa and Mercedes de Mesa, Respondents.
  69. 69G.r. No. 142944 Edenbert Madrigal and Virgilio Mallari, Petitioners, Vs. the Court of Appeals and Jose Mallari, Respondents.
  70. 70G.r. No. 142960 Manila Pearl Corporation, Petitioner, Vs. Manila Pearl Independent Workers Union, Respondent.
  71. 71G.r. No. 147002 Philippine Telegraph & Telephone Corporation and Delia Oficial, Petitioners, Vs. National Labor Relations Commission, Agnes Bayao and Mildred Castillo, Respondents.
  72. 72G.r. No. 149793 Wack Wack Golf & Country Club, Petitioner, Vs. National Labor Relations Commission, Martina G. Cagasan, Carmencita F. Dominguez, and Business Staffing and Management, Inc., Respondents.
  73. 73G.r. No. 150478 Hacienda Bino/hortencia Starke, Inc./hortencia L. Starke, Petitioners, Vs. Candido Cuenca, Francisco Aculit, Angelina Almonia, Donald Alpuerto, Nida Bangalisan, Rogelio Chavez, Elmo Dulinggis, Mercedes Emperado, Toribio Emperado, Juliana Encarnado, Reynaldo Encarnado, Gene Fernando, Joven Fernando, Hernani Fernando, Teresita Fernando, Bonifacio Gadon, Jose Gallada, Ramonito Kilayko, Rolando Kilayko, Alfredo Lastimoso, Antonio Lombo, Elias Lombo, Emma Lombo, Laurencia Lombo, Lucia Lombo, Joel Malacapay, Adela Mojello, Ernesto Mojello, Fructoso Mojello, Jessica Mojello, Jose Mojello, Maritess Mojello, Merlita Mojello, Romeo Mojello, Ronaldo Mojello, Valeriana Mojello, Jaime Nemenzo, Rodolfo Napable, Segundia Ocden, Jardiolina Pabalinas, Lauro Pabalinas, Noli Pabalinas, Ruben Pabalinas, Zaldy Pabalinas, Alfredo Panolino, Joaquin Peduhan, John Peduhan, Reynaldo Peduhan, Rogelio Peduhan, Josephine Peduhan, Antonio Porras, Jr., Lorna Porras, Jimmy Reyes, Alicia Roberto, Marcos Roberto, Jr., Maria Sangga, Rodrigo Sangga, Argene Seron, Samuel Seron, Sr., Angelino Senelong, Armando Senelong, Diolito Senelong, Reynaldo Senelong, Vicente Senelong, Federico Sta. Ana, Rogelio Suasim, Edna Tadlas, Arturo Titong, Jr., Jose Titong, Jr., Nancy Vingno, Alma Yanson, Jimmy Yanson, Myrna Villanueva Belenario, Salvador Malacapay, and Ramelo Tiongco, Respondents.
  74. 74G.r. No. 152481 Ramon Pablo y Bacungan, Petitioner, Vs. People of the Philippines, Respondent.
  75. 75G.r. No. 151303 Athenna* International Manpower Services, Inc., Petitioner, Vs. Nonito Villanos, Respondent.
  76. 76G.r. Nos. 153573-76 People of the Philippines, Appellee, Vs. Wilson Suarez y Villones, Santiago Suarez y Villones (Indeterminate), Ricarte Daria y Tengson (Indeterminate) and Nena Daria y Ripol (Acquitted), Accused. Wilson Suarez y Villones, Appellant.
  77. 77G.r. No. 153777 Planters Development Bank, Petitioner, Vs. Lzk Holdings and Development Corporation, Respondent.
  78. 78G.r. No. 154368 Danzas Intercontinental, Inc., and Claude F. Schaer, Petitioners, Vs. Henry M. Daguman, Amador T. Castro, Richard F. Salvador and Jonas Culala, Respondents.
  79. 79G.r. No. 155181 Liberty Ayo-Alburo, Petitioner, Vs. Uldarico Matobato, Respondent.
  80. 80G.r. No. 161065 Eufemio C. Domingo, Celso D. Gangan, Pacasio S. Banaria, Sofronio B. Ursal, Alberto P. Cruz, Maria L. Matib, Rachel U. Pacpaco, Angelo G. Sanchez, and Sherwin a. Sip-an, Petitioners, Vs. Hon. Guillermo N. Carague, in His Capacity as Chairman, Commission on Audit, Hon. Emmanuel M. Dalman and Hon. Raul C. Flores, in Their Capacities as Commissioners, Commission on Audit, Respondents.
  81. 81G.r. No. 163123 Philippine Health Insurance Corporation, Petitioner, Vs. Chinese General Hospital and Medical Center, Respondent.
  82. 82G.r. No. 152398 Edgar Crisostomo, Petitioner, Vs. Sandiganbayan, Respondent.
  83. 83G.r. No. 144486 Radio Communications of the Philippines, Inc. (Rcpi), Petitioner, Vs. Provincial Assesor of South Cotabato, Provincial Treasurer of South Cotabato, Municipal Assessor of Tupi, South Cotabato, and Municipal Treasurer of Tupi, South Cotabato, Respondents.
  84. 84G.r. No. 148830 National Housing Authority, Petitioner, Vs. Court of Appeals, Bulacan Garden Corporation and Manila Seedling Bank Foundation, Inc., Respondents.
  85. 85G.r. No. 149371 Aberdeen Court, Inc., and Richard Ng, Petitioners, Vs. Mateo C. Agustin Jr., Respondent.
  86. 86A.c. No. 5637 Cristina a. Arienda, Complainant, Vs. Atty. Porfirio Aguila, Respondent.
  87. 87A.m. No. CA-05-18-P [formerly Oca I.p.i. No. 05-80-CA-P] Zaldy Nuez, Complainant, Vs. Elvira Cruz-Apao, Respondent.
  88. 88G.r. No. 118127 City of Manila, Hon. Alfredo S. Lim as the Mayor of the City of Manila, Hon. Joselito L. Atienza, in His Capacity as Vice-Mayor of the City of Manila and Presiding Officer of the City Council of Manila, Hon. Ernesto a. Nieva, Hon. Gonzalo P. Gonzales, Hon. Avelino S. Cailian, Hon. Roberto C. Ocampo, Hon. Alberto Domingo, Hon. Honorio U. Lopez, Hon. Francisco G. Varona, Jr., Hon. Romualdo S. Maranan, Hon. Nestor C. Ponce, Jr., Hon. Humberto B. Basco, Hon. Flaviano F. Concepcion, Jr., Hon. Romeo G. Rivera, Hon. Manuel M. Zarcal, Hon. Pedro S. de Jesus, Hon. Bernardito C. Ang, Hon. Manuel L. Quin, Hon. Jhosep y. Lopez, Hon. Chika G. Go, Hon. Victoriano a. Melendez, Hon. Ernesto v.p. Maceda, Jr., Hon. Rolando P. Nieto, Hon. Danilo v. Roleda, Hon. Gerino a. Tolentino, Jr., Hon. Ma. Paz E. Herrera, Hon. Joey D. Hizon, Hon. Felixberto D. Espiritu, Hon. Karlo Q. Butiong, Hon. Rogelio P. dela Paz, Hon. Bernardo D. Ragaza, Hon. Ma. Corazon R. Caballes, Hon. Casimiro C. Sison, Hon. Bienvinido M. Abante, Jr., Hon. Ma. Lourdes M. Isip, Hon. Alexander S. Ricafort, Hon. Ernesto F. Rivera, Hon. Leonardo L. Angat, and Hon. Jocelyn B. Dawis, in Their Capacity as Councilors of the City of Manila, Petitioners, Vs. Hon. Perfecto a.s. Laguio, Jr., as Presiding Judge, RTC, Manila and Malate Tourist Development Corporation, Respondents.
  89. 89G.r. No. 149765 Arturo Mejia, Petitioner, Vs. Filomena Gabayan, Albin Rueme, Ernesto Mejia, Carlos Ramos, Josefina Lacadin and Pedro Gavino, Respondents.
  90. 90G.r. No. 129472 Marcelo Lasoy and Felix Banisa, Petitioners, Vs. Hon. Monina a. Zenarosa, Presiding Judge, RTC, Br. 76, Quezon City, and the People of the Philippines, Respondents.
  91. 91G.r. No. 134509 Venancio R. Nava, Petitioner, Vs. National Bureau of Investigation, Regional Office No. Xi, Davao City, Respondent.
  92. 92G.r. No. 144095 Spouses Haymaton S. Garingan and Jayyari Pawaki, Petitioners, Vs. Hadji Munib Saupi Garingan, Hadja Tero Saupi Garingan, and Hadja Jehada Saupi Garingan, Respondents.
  93. 93G.r. No. 140954 Heirs of Bertuldo[1] Hinog: Bertuldo Hinog II, Bertuldo Hinog III, Bertuldo Hinog, Jr., Jocelyn Hinog, Bertoldo Hinog IV, Bertoldo Hinog v, Edgardo Hinog, Milagros H. Pabatao, Lilian H. King, Victoria H. Engracia, Terisita C. Hinog, Paz H. Besana, Roberto C. Hinog, Vicente C. Hinog, Roel C. Hinog, Marilyn C. Hinog, Bebot C. Hinog, Lordes C. Hinog, Pablo Chiong, Arlene Lanasang (All Respresented by Bertuldo Hinog III), Petitioners, Vs. Hon. Achilles Melicor, in His Capacity as Presiding Judge, RTC, Branch 4, 7th Judicial Region, Tagbiliran City, Bohol, and Custodio Balane, Rufo Balane, Honorio Balane, and Tomas Balane, Respondents.
  94. 94G.r. No. 140182 Tanay Recreation Center and Development Corp., Petitioner, Vs. Catalina Matienzo Fausto+ and Anunciacion Fausto Pacunayen, Respondents.
  95. 95G.r. No. 139325 Priscilla C. Mijares, Loretta Ann P. Rosales, Hilda B. Narciso, Sr. Mariani Dimaranan, Sfic, and Joel C. Lamangan in Their Behalf and on Behalf of the Class Plaintiffs in Class Action No. Mdl 840, United States District Court of Hawaii, Petitioners, Vs. Hon. Santiago Javier Ranada, in His Capacity as Presiding Judge of Branch 137, Regional Trial Court, Makati City, and the Estate of Ferdinand E. Marcos, Through Its Court Appointed Legal Representatives in Class Action Mdl 840, United States District Court of Hawaii, Namely: Imelda R. Marcos and Ferdinand Marcos, Jr., Respondents.
  96. 96G.r. Nos. 151809-12 Presidential Commission on Good Government (Pcgg), Petitioner, Vs. Sandiganbayan (Fifth Division), Lucio C. Tan, Carmen Khao Tan, Florencio T. Santos, Natividad P. Santos, Domingo Chua, Tan Hui Nee, Mariano Tan Eng Lian, Estate of Benito Tan Kee Hiong (Represented by Tarciana C. Tan), Florencio N. Santos, Jr., Harry C. Tan, Tan Eng Chan, Chung Poe Kee, Mariano Khoo, Manuel Khoo, Miguel Khoo, Jaime Khoo, Elizabeth Khoo, Celso Ranola, William T. Wong, Ernesto B. Lim, Benjamin T. Albacita, Willy Co, Allied Banking Corp., Allied Leasing and Finance Corporation, Asia Brewery, Inc., Basic Holdings Corp., Foremost Farms, Inc., Fortune Tobacco Corp., Grandspan Development Corp., Himmel Industries, Iris Holdings and Development Corp., Jewel Holdings, Inc., Manufacturing Services and Trade Corp., Maranaw Hotels and Resort Corp., Northern Tobacco Redrying Plant, Progressive Farms, Inc., Shareholdings, Inc., Sipalay Trading Corp., Virgo Holdings & Development Corp., and Atty. Estelito P. Mendoza, Respondents.
  97. 97G.r. No. 155009 Simeon M. Valdez, Petitioner, Vs. China Banking Corporation, Respondent.
  98. 98G.r. No. 156047 Engr. Pedro C. Rubio, Jr., Petitioner, Vs. Hon. Emmanuel M. Paras, Administrator, National Irrigation Administration (Nia), Respondent.
  99. 99G.r. No. 158138 Philippine Bank of, Communications, Petitioner, Vs. Elena Lim, Ramon Calderon, and Tri-Oro International Trading & Manufacturing Corporation, Respondents.
  100. 100G.r. No. 162733 Erasmo Tayao, Petitioner, Vs. Rosa D. Mendoza and the Director of Lands, Respondents.
  101. 101G.r. No. 165751 Datu Guimid P. Matalam, Petitioner, Vs. the Second Division of the Sandiganbayan and the People of the Philippines, Respondents.
  102. 102A.m. No. P-05-1934 (Formerly Oca I.p.i. No. 03-1693-P) Jose and Milagros Villaceran, Complainants, Vs. Wilmer M. Beltejar, Sheriff III, Municipal Trial Court in Cities, Santiago City, Branch 2, Respondent.
  103. 103G.r. No. 139018 Estherlita Cruz-Agana, Petitioner, Vs. Hon. Judge Aurora Santiago-Lagman (in Her Capacity as Presiding Judge of Regional Trial Court, Branch 77, Malolos, Bulacan) and B. Serrano Enterprises, Inc., Respondents.
  104. 104G.r. No. 143380 Olimpio Pangonorom and Metro Manila Transit Corporation, Petitioners, Vs. People of the Philippines, Respondent.
  105. 105G.r. No. 150897 Turadio C. Domingo, Petitioner, Vs. Jose C. Domingo, Leonora Domingo-Castro and Her Spouse Juanito Castro, Nuncia Domingo-Balabis, Abella Domingo Valencerina and the Register of Deeds, Quezon City, Respondents.
  106. 106G.r. No. 150915 (Rab-11-01-00108-99) Mario Manaban, Alejandro Estacion, Danilo Linggas, Eusebio Toralba, Jerry Sulano, Mario Linggas, Carlito Tipon, Alvin Rosas, Renato Toralba, Ely Morente, Antonio Gonzaga, Romeo Bahinting, Dionesio Dumait, Pedro Amodia, Romeo Langtad, Loreto Arlas, Patricio Biabado, Jesus Diego, Eduardo Tangaro, Francisco Denivar, Victoriano Rosas, Ernesto Pestaño, Wellam Rosas, Mario Caduhay, Ronald Tuga-Ob, Ronald R.c. Tagaub, Virgelio Mamugas, Severo Barangoy, Demetrio Otero, Sotio Lantomen, Faustino Avila, Jr., Ricardo Espellarga, Pampilo Ayala, Nestor Diaz, Cairus Tugaub, Sr., Marjoseph Matas, Camilo Raymundo, Rocete Antusen, Juanito Espellarga, Alfrido Tabacon, Elezer Avila, Ruben Tugaub, Rocello Auxillio, Floriano Avila, Aniano Gayod, Jesus Maloloy-on, Roceto Pales, Sabas Raymundo, Rodrigo Dunayre, Rolando Reyes, Martin Tugaob, Julio Sulano, Claro Tugaob, Ernesto Verina, Armando Ayala, Angelito Ayala, Jose Dunayre, Verlito Ayala, Jesus Estalane, Custodio Gaña, Emerzon Diego, Romeo Lino, Marcelo Naraga, Norberto Sulano, Carolina Maloloy-on, Jessie Requino, Aida Villarin, Vicente Paraiso, Bernadeta Gayod, Alejandro Cabeldo, Fructuso Retanal, Nelson Laguruan, Ana Gatuco, Bonifacio Macula, Carlos Gonzaga, Premitivo Tabacan, Enriqueta Tugaub, Rodolfo Matas, Faustino Sarnillo, Faustino Lindio, Teofilo Diego, Glecerio Gayod, Cairos Tugaob, Jr., Efren Gonzaga, Catalino Candestable, Oscar Aruma, Merlina Anuada, Leopoldo Boliver, Rosita Ayala, Esmael Lupian, Adela Cagatin, Federico Devivar, Sr., Monica Veriña, Manolito Veriña, Jolito Veriña, Ceperina Matas, Samuela Caduhay, Joseph Lupian, Raulito Babiado, and Trade Union of the Philippines and Allied Services (Tupas), Petitioners, Vs. Sarphil Corporation/apokon Fruits, Inc., Lorenzo Sarmiento, Jr., and Salvador T. Balbuena, Respondents. (Rab-Xi-03-00298-99) Alexander Raymundo, Alvin Caduhay, Rodolfo Perado, Joel Caduhay, Mercedito Mating, Lito Latiban, Miguel Alboro, Pedro Espellarga, Antonio Castil, Elina Linggas, Cesar Amboayon, Mamerto Lavanza, William Dunig and Trade Union of the Philippines and Allied Services (Tupas), Petitioners, Vs. Sarphil Corporation/apokon Fruits, Inc., Lorenzo Sarmiento, Jr., and Salvador T. Balbuena, Respondents. (Rab-Xi-03-00322-99) Roberto Latras, Roberto Tugaob and Trade Union of the Philippines and Allied Services (Tupas), Petitioners, Vs. Sarphil Corporation/apokon Fruits, Inc., Lorenzo Sarmiento, Jr., and Salvador T. Balbuena, Respondents. (Rab-Xi-03-00377-99) Blasa Bautista, Filizardo Fial, and Trade Union of the Philippines and Allied Services (Tupas), Petitioners, Vs. Sarphil Corporation/apokon Fruits, Inc., Lorenzo Sarmiento, Jr., and Salvador T. Balbuena, Respondents. (Rab-Xi-00360-99) Alan Eder, Romeo Zuzada, Edwin Zuzada, Efrime Zuzada, Marcelo Zuzada, Zoilo Gonzaga, Raymundo Uyanguren, Rodolfo Gonzaga, Raulito Madrid, Dionesio Malub, Vitoriano Nipa, and Trade Union of the Philippines and Allied Services (Tupas), Petitioners, Vs. Sarphil Corporation/apokon Fruits, Inc., Lorenzo Sarmiento, Jr., and Salvador T. Balbuena, Respondents. (Rab-Xi-04-00390-99) Renato Anuba, Eduardo Linggas, and Trade Union of the Philippines and Allied Services (Tupas), Petitioners, Vs. Sarphil Corporation/apokon Fruits, Inc., Lorenzo Sarmiento, Jr., and Salvador T. Balbuena, Respondents. (Rab-Xi-07-00825-99) Ricky Benial, Calixto Raymundo, Alma Gaña, Marilyn Abante, Edwin Maloloy-on, Reynaldo Superable, and Trade Union of the Philippines and Allied Services (Tupas), Petitioners, Vs. Sarphil Corporation/apokon Fruits, Inc., Lorenzo Sarmiento, Jr., and Salvador T. Balbuena, Respondents. (Rab-Xi-08-00959-99) Aurora Ayala, and Trade Union of the Philippines and Allied Services (Tupas), Petitioners, Vs. Sarphil Corporation/apokon Fruits, Inc., Lorenzo Sarmiento, Jr., and Salvador T. Balbuena, Respondents.
  107. 107G.r. No. 157781 Robert Crisanto D. Lee, Petitioner, Vs. People of the Philippines and Atoz Trading Corporation, Respondents.
  108. 108G.r. No. 164857 Flexo Manufacturing Corporation, Petitioner, Vs. Columbus Foods, Incorporated and Pacific Meat Company, Incorporated, Respondents.
  109. 109G.r. No. 140777 Antonio Abacan, Jr., Rufo C. Venus, Jr., Enriqueto I. Magpantay and Marieta y. Palanca, Petitioners, Vs. Northwestern University, Inc., Respondent.
  110. 110G.r. No. 152039 F.f. Marine Corporation and/or Mr. Eric a. Cruz, Petitioners, Vs. the Honorable Second Division National Labor Relations Commission and Ricardo M. Magno, Respondents.
  111. 111G.r. No. 161135 Swagman Hotels and Travel, Inc., Petitioner, Vs. Hon. Court of Appeals, and Neal B. Christian, Respondents.
  112. 112G.r. No. 136062 Trifilo Montebon, Petitioner, Vs. Atty. Corazon Tanglao-Dacanay, Legal Counsel and/or Office of the Ombudsman, Robert Lim, and Edwin Salimbangon, Respondents.
  113. 113G.r. No. 151922 Amelita M. Escareal, Rubirosa Versoza and Dave Francisco M. Velasco, Petitioners, Vs. Philippine Airlines, Inc., Patria T. Chiong, Jorge Ma. Cui, Jr., National Labor Relations Commission (3rd Division), Respondents.
  114. 114A.m. No. Mtj-02-1452 (Formerly Oca Ipi No. 01-1119-Mtj) Editha O. Catbagan, Complainant, Vs. Judge Felixberto P. Barte, Municipal Circuit Trial Court, Tobias Fornier, Antique, Respondent.
  115. 115A.m. No. P-05-1974 Rodolfo T. Baquerfo, Complainant, Vs. Gerry C. Sanchez, Legal Researcher II, Regional Trial Court, Branch 28, Lianga, Surigao del Sur, Respondent.
  116. 116A.m. No. P-05-1981 (Formerly Oca I.p.i. No. 02-1516-P) Civil Service Commission, Petitioner, Vs. Emma S. Javier, Utility Worker I, Respondent.
  117. 117A.m. No. Rtj-05-1909 Community Rural Bank of Guimba (N. E.), Inc., Represented by Olga M. Samson, Complainant, Vs. Judge Tomas B. Talavera, Regional Trial Court (Branch 28), Cabanatuan City, Nueva Ecija, Respondent.
  118. 118G.r. No. 134155 Angelito Uy, Petitioner, Vs. Pableo S. Baloja, Respondent.
  119. 119G.r. No. 147812 Leonardo R. Ocampo, Petitioner, Vs. Leonora Tirona, Respondent.
  120. 120G.r. No. 162270 Abacus Real Estate Development Center, Inc., Petitioner, Vs. the Manila Banking Corporation, Respondent.
  121. 121G.r. No. 150129 Norma a. Abdulla, Petitioner, Vs. People of the Philippines, Respondent.